Iain HAY . Defending letters: A pragmatic response to assaults on the humanities[J]. PROGRESS IN GEOGRAPHY, 2018 , 37(3) : 317 -326 . DOI: 10.18306/dlkxjz.2018.03.002

[1]	4Humanities. 2015. Mission[EB/OL]. 2015-04[2018-03-25].

[2]	American Academy of Arts and Sciences.2013. The heart of the matter[R]. Cambridge, MA: American Academy of Arts and Sciences.

[3]	American Academy of Arts and Sciences. 2015. National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH) Funding Levels[R/OL]. 2015-10[2018-03-25].

[4]	Batstone M. 2012. In defence of the humanities[N/OL]. The Guardian. 2012-01-11[2018-03-25]. .

[5]	Bertolt B.1964. Brecht on theatre: The development of an aesthetic[M]. John Willett, Trans. New York: Hill and Wang.

[6]	Billotte K. 2012. Conservatives killed the liberal arts[N/OL]. Salon, 2012-09-15[2018-03-25]. .

[7]	Bonnell A. 2014. Humanities & social science under attack[J/OL]. Advocate, 21(1). .

[8]

Brindley A.1999. The role of backyards in suburban life: A case study: Millswood, Adelaide[J]. South Australian Geographical Journal, 98: 61-77.Informit is an online service offering a wide range of database and full content publication products that deliver the vast majority of Australasian scholarly research to the education, research and business sectors. Informit is the brand that encompasses RMIT Publishing's online products: Informit Indexes, Informit Plus Text and Informit Collections.

[9]	Campaign for Social Science.2015. The business of people: The significance of social science over the next decade[M]. London: Sage.

[10]

Cech T R.1999. Science at liberal arts colleges: A better education?[J] Daedalus, 128: 195-216.A discussion of science education at liberal arts colleges looks at empirical data on the success of their graduates in comparison with graduates of research universities, how the classroom and research experiences at the two institution types compare, and why the top liberal arts colleges appear to be so successful in training successful scientists. (MSE) DOI

[11]	Christ C T. 2005. A world of experiences: We must prepare our students to live in a smaller world. Smith Alumnae. Spring[EB/OL]. 2015-05-17 [2018-03-25]. .

[12]	Christie M.1992. Grounded and ex-centric knowledges: Exploring Aboriginal alternatives to western thinking[Z]. Paper presented at the Fifth International Conference on Thinking, Townsville, Queensland.

[13]

Coghlan C.2014. Australia and live animal export: Wronging nonhuman animals[J]. Journal of Animal Ethics, 4(2): 45-60. doi:10.5406/janimalethics.4.2.0045.The decades-old trade of exporting nonhuman mammals by ship from Australia became a major political issue in 2011, when video taken by animal rights group Animals Australia was broadcast on television, showing Australian cattle being appallingly abused in Indonesian abattoirs. Taking its cue from the unprecedented response from Australians to the 2011 footage, many of whom were haunted by the video images, this article argues that the live export trade may be seen to wrong nonhuman animals according to several key ethical frameworks. DOI

[14]

de Rosa M.2003. Privacy in the age of terror[J]. The Washington Quarterly, 26(3): 27-41. doi:10.1162/016366003765609552.Providing security without threatening civil liberties requires a new model to protect individual privacy—one that relies less on prohibiting the collection and dissemination of private information and more on effective oversight and control of government activity. DOI

[15]	Dean A. 2015. Japan's humanities chop sends shivers down academic spines[N/OL]. The Guardian. 2015-09-26[2018-03-25]. .

[16]

Dear M.1988. The postmodern challenge: Reconstructing human geography[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 13(3): 262-274. doi:10.2307/622990.In this paper, I argue in favour of regarding human geography as part of the social theory movement. By confronting the intellectual disarray in human geography, and addressing the challenge of postmodernism and deconstruction, the discipline could attain a pivotal role in the social sciences and humanities. DOI

[17]	Deresiewicz W.2014. Excellent sheep: The miseducation of the American elite and the way to a meaningful life[M]. New York: Free Press.

[18]	Douglas W, Neal J.2013. Engaging the Muslim world: Public diplomacy after 9/11 in the Arab Middle East, Afghanistan, and Pakistan[M]. Boulder, CO: Rowman and Littlefield.

[19]	Else H.2014. Students unrealistic about skill level of jobs[N/OL]. Times Higher Education. 2014-06-26[2018-03-25]. .

[20]	Faust D G. 2010. The role of the university in a changing world[Z/OL]. 2010-06-30[2018-03-25]. .

[21]	Foucault M.1988. Power/knowledge: Selected interviews and other writings, 1972-1977[M]. New York, NY: Random House.

[22]	French T, LaBerge L, Magill P. 2011. We're all marketers now[J/OL]. McKinsey Quarterly, 2011-12-18[2018-03-25].

[23]	Fulbright J W, Tillman S P.1989. The price of empire[M]. New York: Pantheon.

[24]

Garden R.2015. Who speaks for whom? Health humanities and the ethics of representation[J]. Medical Humanities, 41(2): 77-80. doi:10.1136/medhum-2014-010642.Abstract The medical or health humanities are in essence a form of advocacy, a means of addressing a problem of underrepresentation. They focus on suffering, rather than pathology, and on sociocultural understandings of illness and disability, rather than a narrow biomedical perspective. The health humanities thus analyse and attempt to recalibrate the power imbalance in healthcare. This article reviews health humanities scholarship that addresses underrepresentation through the analysis of illness and disability narratives. It examines the ethics of representation by exploring how literary representation functions, its aesthetic as well as political dimensions, and how it operates as a relay mechanism for power. The mechanism of representation is further explored through a reading of Eli Clare's narrative Exile and Pride. Donna Haraway's notion of articulations is proposed as a tool for a more ethical approach to representation. The article suggests that transparency about the power health humanities scholars stand to gain through representation may contribute to a more ethical health humanities practice. Published by the BMJ Publishing Group Limited. For permission to use (where not already granted under a licence) please go to http://group.bmj.com/group/rights-licensing/permissions. DOI PMID

[25]

Gentzler J.2003. What is a death with dignity?[J]. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 28(4): 461-487. doi:10.1076/jmep.28.4.461.15968.Proponents of the legalization of assisted suicide often appeal to our supposed right to “die with dignity” to defend their case. I examine and assess different notions of “dignity” that are operating in many arguments for the legalization of assisted suicide, and I find them all to be deficient. I then consider an alternative conception of dignity that is based on Aristotle's conception of the conditions on the best life. I conclude that, while such a conception of dignity fits best with our intuitions about the conditions under which a life has dignity, it supports the legalization of assisted suicide only under very limited circumstances. DOI PMID

[26]

Ginn F, Beisel U, Barua M.2014. Flourishing with awkward creatures: Togetherness, vulnerability, killing[J]. Environmental Humanities, 4: 113-123. doi:10.1215/22011919-3614953.react-text: 428 The southern Peak District, like many rural regions of the United Kingdom privileges a particular 'way of seeing' the landscape, a Romantic spectacle reinforced in contemporary heritage practices. Yet the spectacle contains a series of fragments and spaces that resist easy categorisation. This paper proposes a way to account for some of these fragments of the landscape by foregrounding how... /react-text react-text: 429 /react-text [Show full abstract] DOI

[27]	Giroux H A. 2011. Beyond the swindle of the corporate university: Higher education in the service of democracy[Z/OL]. Truthout, 2011-01-18[2018-03-25]. .

[28]	Grove J.2015. Social sciences and humanities faculties 'to close' in Japan after ministerial intervention[N/OL]. Times Higher Education, 2015-09-14[2018-03-25]. .

[29]	Gruen D, Kelly J, Gorecki S, et al. 2011. Wellbeing, living standards and their distribution[J/OL]. Economic Roundup, (3): 81-98[2018-03-25]. .

[30]	Hall D E.2013. The value of the liberal arts in an undergraduate education: Address to the Lehigh Tower Society[Z/OL]. 2013-09-28[2018-03-25]. .

[31]	Hay I, Beaverstock J.2016. Handbook on wealth and the super-rich[M]. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.

[32]	Hay I, Muller S.2014. Questioning generosity in the golden age of philanthropy: Towards critical geographies of super-philanthropy[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 38: 635-653. doi:10.1177/0309132513500893. DOI

[33]	Head L, Muir P.2013. Backyard[M]. Ultimo, NSW: Halstead Press.

[34]

Hohendahl P U.2005. The future of the research university and the fate of the humanities[J]. Cultural Critique, 61(1): 1-21. doi:10.1353/cul.2005.0033.In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content: html_title The Future of the Research University and the Fate of the Humanities /html_title Peter Uwe Hohendahl (bio) The American research university has received a great deal of attention during the past decade or so, mostly by concerned observers who believe that the research university is in danger of losing its crucial role in the American system of higher education (Ehrenberg; Cole, Barber, and Graubard; Whiston and Geiger). Under these circumstances, a discussion of its future and its potential impact on the development of the humanities in particular, appears to be a difWcult and potentially not-very-rewarding task. If the skeptics are correct in their analysis, the university's future is at best uncertain, which means that the fate of the humanities as part of the research university is equally uncertain. Among the critics of the more recent evolution of the university we find, for instance, Bill Readings, who has argued that the new university (by which he means mostly the research university) is more interested in the excellence of its administration and its national reputation than in its commitment to the subject matter of teaching or research. The "university of excellence" strives for public recognition without much regard for the values that once defined the idea of a university. By contrasting the contemporary American or international university with Humboldt's ideal of the university, Readings gets the fuel for his highly suggestive and far-reaching polemic without paying too much attention to the actual evolution of the American research university during the twentieth century and its more recent difficulties. However, these problems must be examined in more specific terms than Readings's rather general charges allow (for a critical assessment, see LaCapra). Therefore I propose to begin with a brief account of the present state of the American research university by examining the more recent development of its central elements before I address the complex [End Page 1] question of its future and its likely impact on the humanities. This present state has frequently been described in terms of a crisis, especially in the humanities (Hohendahl 2000), yet we should keep in mind that the social sciences have not necessarily done better, and even the natural sciences, although they have traditionally been considered the successful core of the modern research university (Geiger 1986, Geiger 1993), these days find themselves in a discouraging financial environment. The very notion of research as a process of cognitive learning unhindered by pressures that are unrelated to the idea of scientific work can no longer be taken for granted. Observers such as Charles M. Vest and Neal Lane have pointed out that the methods and expectations of doing research in the academy have definitely changed during the past two decades. The use of the term "crisis" for these changes still presupposes the notion that we can overcome the present problems and then return to a state of normalcy that would look more like the past than the dreaded present. However, it seems to me that such a return to a status quo ante is unlikely; in other words, many of the changes that have occurred have to be understood as irreversible transformations. The research university of the twenty-first century will, I believe, significantly differ from the model of the mid-twentieth century that we still in many ways consider the norm. Furthermore, I feel that the changes of the past twenty years are a reasonably good indication of the direction in which the research university will develop. In the following analysis I want to focus on selected aspects of this transformation. I will do this in the form of theses rather than by way of a full and systematic analysis. In these theses I will address several issues, among them the political and social environment of the university, its organizational structure, and the definition of research in different fields. What I want to show is that the function of the research university has been altered. In particular, cultural, social, and political expectations have changed and therefore also the climate in which the institution has to operate. Needless to say, the humanities have not remained unaffected by these transformations. The history of the American research... DOI

[35]	Hopkins K. 2014. A liberal arts degree is a waste of time[N/OL]. The Spectator, 2014-02-14[2018-03-25]. .

[36]	Institute for the Future. 2011. Future work skills 2020[R/OL]. [2018-03-25]. .

[37]	Lehrer J. 2011. Steve jobs: 'Technology alone is not enough'[J/OL]. The New Yorker, 2011-10-07[2018-03-25]. Retrieved from .

[38]	Lewin T. 2013. As interest fades in the humanities, colleges worry[N/OL]. The New York Times, 2013-10-30[2018-03-25]. .

[39]	Matthews D.2013. Spinach for its own sake[Z/OL]. 2013-04- 25[2018-03-25]. .

[40]

McLean M R.2005. The future of food: An introduction to the ethical issues in genetically modified foods[Z/OL]. 2005-04[2018-03-25]. Paper presented at the conference entitled The Future of Food: Legal and Ethical Challenges held at Santa Clara University, California.The author first presented this information at the conference: The Future of Food: Legal and Ethical Challenges held at Santa Clara University, California. The author outlines the potential benefits and risks of genetically modified foods to the environment, human health and the economy.

[41]	McLeod C M. 2004. Pondering nature: An ethnography of duck hunting in southern New Zealand[D/OL]. [2018-03-25]. Dunedin: University of Otago, New Zealand. .

[42]	McLoughlin K. 2014. Authoring war: The literary representation of war from the Iliad to Iraq[M]. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.

[43]	Brandy Schillace. 2015. Medical humanities in conversation[Z/OL]. [2018-03-25].

[44]

Miller J H.2014. What ought humanists to do?[J] Daedalus, 143(1): 19-34. doi:10.1162/DAED_a_00250.The article discusses how social frictions within the Livonian peasantry manifested themselves in times of hunger and how the authorities sought to combat the situation in the 1840s and late 1860s. After the emancipation reforms of 1816-19, provision for the peasantry was left solely to communal and public institutions. When reserves became scarce, community authorities were able to seek a loan from the manor (in the 1840s) or apply for a state advance loan. Community authorities were mean when it came to grain loans to the landless who formed the majority of the community members. Although community leaders played a role in insufficient hunger relief in the 1840s, the main culprits for the mass sufferings were the landlords' selfishness or carelessness and the government's reluctance to grant loans. In the late 1860s the scope of hunger relief to the landless depended almost entirely on community authorities. Self-seeking community authorities could effectively block relief loans to the landless. DOI

[45]	Mittelstrass J.2015. Humanities under pressure[J]. Humanities, 4: 80-86. doi:10.3390/h4010080. DOI

[46]	National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine.2015. Integration of Education in the Humanities, Science, Engineering and Medicine[R/OL]. 2015-07-27[2018-03-27]. .

[47]	Newfield C.2010. Avoiding the coming higher ed wars. American Association of University Professors[R/OL]. 2010-May-June[2018-03-27]. .

[48]	Nussbaum M. 2010. Cultivating the imagination[N/OL]. The New York Times, 2010-10-17[2018-03-25]. .

[49]	OECD. 2016. Future of Work in Figures[R/OL]. 2016-01-14[2018-03-25]. .

[50]	OECD Labour and Employment Ministerial Meeting. 2016. Ministerial statement. Building more resilient and inclusive labour markets. Paris: Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development[R/OL]. 2016-01-15[2018-03-26].

[51]	Owen W.1920. Poems[M]. London: Chatto and Windus.

[52]	PBO (Parliamentary Budget Office). 2016. Higher education loan program: Impact on the budget[R]. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia. (Report No. 02/2016).

[53]

Phamotse M, Kissack M.2008. The role of the humanities in the modern university: Some historical and philosophical considerations[J]. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 42(1): 49-65. doi:10.1111/jope.2008.42.issue-1.Abstract This article examines the controversial notion of the role and value of the humanities in the contemporary university. It provides a review of the history of the emergence of the humanities in the European universities, arguing that any attempt to justify the presence of the humanities in the modern university in instrumental terms is futile. Through its depiction of the evolution of the humanities as a particular compendium of disciplinary fields, the article demonstrates that the humanities have become a focal point for the exploration of the problems of meaning, significance and truth, which are inherent components of language itself. Through its portrayal of the historical development of the humanities, the article emphasizes the interminable nature of these problems, stressing that the inconclusive quality of these debates is a definitive feature of Modernity itself he humanities have become the locus for Modernity's self-awareness. The articulation and extension of this self-awareness is an imperative that eludes the logic of instrumental reason to provide a justificatory category of its own. DOI

[54]	Preston A. 2015. The war against humanities at Britain's universities[N/OL]. The Guardian, 2015-03-29[2018-03-25]. .

[55]	Romano H. 2016. A tale of two Berkeleys[N/OL]. The Daily Californian, 2016-01-13[2018-03-25]. .

[56]	Sawa T. 2015. Humanities under attack[N/OL]. The Japan Times, 2015-08-23[2018-03-25]. .

[57]	Sayer A.2000. Realism and social science[M]. London: Sage.

[58]	Scalia C J. 2015. Conservatives, please stop thrashing the liberal arts[N/OL]. The Wall Street Journal, 2015-03-27[2018-03-25]. .

[59]	Shaw R. 2015. Opinion: BA myth-busting overdue[EB/OL]. Massey University: About. 201512-17[2018-03-25]. .

[60]	Smith J K A.2006. Who's afraid of postmodernism? Taking Derrida, Lyotard and Foucault to church[M]. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Academic.

[61]	Soja E.1989. Postmodern geographies: The reassertion of space in critical social theory[M]. London: Verso.

[62]	Souter D.2010. Harvard commencement 2010[Z/OL]. 2010-05-27[2018-03-25]. .

[63]	Starr P.2013. Remedy and reaction: The peculiar American struggle over health care reform[M]. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

[64]	Terras M, Priego E, Liu A, et al. 2013. The Humanities Matter![R/OL]. 2013-07[2018-03-26]. .

[65]

Trimper J B, Wolpe P R, Rommelfanger K S.2014. When “I” becomes “We”: Ethical implications of emerging brain-to-brain interfacing technologies[J]. Frontiers in Neuroengineering, 7(4): 1-4. doi:10.3389/fneng.2014.00004.When “I” becomes “We”: ethical implications of emerging brain-to-brain interfacing technologies DOI PMID

[66]	UC Berkeley. 2018. Big ideas courses[Z/OL]. 2018-03-26[2018-03-26]. .

[67]	Wadhwa V, Freeman R B, Rissing B A.2008. Education and Tech Entrepreneurship[R/OL]. 2008-05-01[2018-03-25]. .

[68]	Walker P. 2015. England has highest university tuition fees in industrialised world, survey finds[N/OL]. The Guardian, 2015-11-24[2018-03-25]. .

[69]	Wilsdon J, Walker D. Social science is vital too[N/OL]. The Guardian. 2015-12-06[2018-03-25]. .