全球化视角的区域主义与区域一体化理论阐释

doi:10.11820/dlkxjz.2013.07.011

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 区域一体化作为重要的区域发展模式, 历来是地理学者关注的焦点。本文通过对区域一体化相关概念的辨析, 回顾区域主义发展历程, 并概括全球化赋予区域一体化的新内涵, 提出目前区域一体化研究的不足之处, 以期为区域经济发展研究提供有益的启示。区域主义与全球化是塑造当今世界经济格局的两种重要的力量, 自19世纪以来, 区域主义就伴随着全球化的趋势产生了4 次思想浪潮的变革;与此同时, 区域一体化的理论趋于系统化, 从早期的关税同盟理论、自由区贸易理论、大市场理论等以国际贸易为重点, 转而向空间、制度等方面扩展, 引入了新区域主义、新经济地理理论和新制度经济学等研究视角。随着区域行为主体的多元化、合作领域的深化、组织机制的复杂化, 形成了全球化背景下区域一体化新的内涵。根据国外的研究进展和国内区域一体化的现实需求, 未来应该对主权国家内部跨界一体化理论、内涵等方面加强研究。

关键词: 理论综述, 区域一体化, 区域主义, 全球化

Abstract: As one of the important paradigms for regional cooperation, regional integration has been receiving extensive attention from scholars, especially in the field of geography. In today’s globalizing world, regional integration is one of the driving forces that reshape the world’s politics and economies. Especially, a considerable amount of research interest has been focused on how the emergence of regional integration after the World War Ⅱ has affected, and will continue to affect, the global economy. However, it is widely accepted that regionalism is not just a recent phenomenon. There have arisen at least four waves of regionalism since the 19th century, along with the trend of globalization. The first wave occurred during the second half of the 19th century and was characterized by colonization. After World War Ⅱ, regionalism demonstrated some new traits and began to pave a peaceful path. Soon after that, a plethora of regional trade blocs formed against the backdrop of the Cold War. With the advent of the 21th century, the most recent wave of regionalism has arisen in a more globalized context than the earlier ones. Because the current regionalism creates the new forms of regional organization, co-existing with traditional forms of state-led governance at the national level, not only the forces driving the current regionalism but also the context and features of the new regional integration are radically different. Consequently, with the“new regionalism”wave, regional integration has become a multidimensional process with implications for bilateral/multilateral trade liberalization as well as the dimensions of politics, security, culture and institutions. In the meantime, theoretical framework used to analyze the political and economic impact of the implementation of regional integration have been systematically improved; new regionalism, new economic geographies and new institutional economics have been introduced to the analysis of regional governance, spatial equilibrium and institutional construction of regional cooperation. This transformation greatly contributes to diversification of the implications of regional integration, including its agents, content of cooperation and organizational mechanism. Nevertheless, there are some issues to be further studied in future. Based on the development process of regional integration, this paper first differentiates regional integration from other related concepts, and then reviews the developmental path of regionalism in the context of globalization in which regionalism has gone through four stages. At last, by summarizing important economic and political theories about regional integration in the literature, which provide reference and inspiration for the regional study, this paper makes a brief comment on the strengths or weaknesses of those established theories, and raises several questions for the current research on regional integration.

Key words: globalization, regional integration, regionalism, review

王珏, 陈雯. 全球化视角的区域主义与区域一体化理论阐释[J]. 地理科学进展, 2013, 32(7): 1082-1091.

WANG Jue, CHEN Wen. Implication of regionalism and regional integration under the global shift[J]. PROGRESS IN GEOGRAPHY, 2013, 32(7): 1082-1091.

参考文献

[1] Akira K. 2002. A note on globalization and regional integration// Park S-J, Hirowatari S. Strategies towards globalization: European and Japanese perspectives. Berlin, Germany: Freie Universität Berlin, Institute for East Asia Studies: 309-338.
[2] An H S, Li R L. 2007. The effect and development path of regional economic integration. Hunan Social Sciences, (5): 95-102. [安虎森, 李瑞林. 2007. 区域经济一体化效应和实现途径. 湖南社会科学, (5): 95-102.]
[3] Balassa B A. 1961. The theory of economic integration. New York: Greenwood Press.
[4] Bernstein R A. 1972. International integration: Multidimensional or unidimensional? Journal of Conflict Resolution, 16(3): 403-408.
[5] Best E. 1997. Capacities for regional integration: A conceptual framework for comparative analysis//Madeleine O H, Avlid S. Free trade agreements and customs unions: Experience, challenges and constraints. Maasttricht, Limburg Provincie, Netherlands: European Commission: 51-75.
[6] Breslin S, Higgott R. 2000. Studying regions: Learning from the old, constructing the new. New Political Economy, 5 (3): 333-352.
[7] Castells M. 2001. The rise of the network society. Xia Z J, Wang Z H, Ying B N, et al, Trans.. Beijing, China: Social Sciences Academic Press. [Castells M. 2001. 网络社会的崛起. 夏铸九, 王志弘, 殷宝宁, 等, 译. 北京: 社会科学文献出版社.]
[8] Chen X M. 1995. The evolution of free economic zones and the recent development of cross-national growth zones.
[9] International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 19 (4): 593-621.
[10] Coase R H. 1960. The problem of social cost. Journal of Law and Economics, 3: 1-44.
[11] Cohen R B. 1981. The new international division of labor, multinational corporation and urban hierarchy//Dear M J, Scott A J. Urbanization and urban planning in capitalist society. London: Taylor and Francis: 287-315.
[12] Combes P P, Mayer T, Thisse J F. 2011. Economic geography: The integration of regions and nations. An H S, Yan Y G, Xu Y, et al, Trans.. Beijing, China: China Renmin University Press. [Combes P P, Mayer T, Thisse J F. 2011. 经济地理学: 区域和国家一体化. 安虎森, 颜银根, 徐杨, 等, 译. 北京: 中国人民大学出版社.]
[13] Corden W M. 1972. Economies of scale and customs union theory. The Journal of Political Economy, 80(3): 465-475.
[14] De Lombaerde P, van Langenhove L. 2006. Assessment and measurement of regional integration. London: Routledge.
[15] Dicken P. 2007. Global shift: Reshaping the global economic map in the 21st century. Liu W D, Trans.. Beijing, China: The Comercial Press. [Dicken P. 2007. 全球性转变: 重塑 21 世纪的全球经济地图. 刘卫东, 译. 北京: 商务印书馆.]
[16] Edward M, Milner H. 1999. The new wave of regionalism. International Organization, 53(3): 589-627.
[17] Eichengreen B, Jeffrey A F. 1995. Economic regionalism: Evidence from two 20th century episodes. North American Journal of Economics and Finance, 6(2): 89-106.
[18] Erll A. 2010. Regional integration and (trans)cultural memory. Asia Europe Journal, 8(3): 305-315.
[19] Friedmann J. 1986. The world city hypothesis. Development and Change, 17(1): 69-83.
[20] Hall P. 1966. The world cities. New York: McGraw-Hill.
[21] Hettne B. 1999. Globalization and the new regionalism: The second great transformation//Hettne B, Inotai A, Osvaldo S. Globalism and the new regionalism. London: Macmillan Press: 1-24.
[22] Hettne B, Söderbaum F. 2006. Regional cooperation: A tool for addressing regional and global challenges. Stockholm: Secretariat of the International Task Force on Global Public Goods.
[23] Hurrell A. 1995. Regionalism in theoretical perspective//Fawcett L, Hurrell A. Regionalism in world politics: Regional organization and international order. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press: 37-73.
[24] Hveem H. 2000. Explaining the regional phenomenon in an era of globalization//Richard S, Geoffrey R D. Political economy and the changing global order. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press: 70-81.
[25] Irwin D A. 1993. Multilateral and bilateral trade policies in the world trading system: An historical perspective//Jaime D M, Arvind P. New dimensions in regional integration. New York: Cambridge University Press: 90-119.
[26] Isard W. 1956. Regional science, the concept of region, and regional structure. Papers in Regional Science, 2(1): 13-26.
[27] Kemp M C, Wan H. 1976. An elementary proposition concerning the formation of customs unions. Journal of International Economics, 6(1): 95-97.
[28] Krugman P R, Venables A J. 1995. Globalization and the inequality of nations. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 110 (4):857-880.
[29] Lawrence R Z. 1996. Regionalism, multilateralism, and deeper integration.Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
[30] Li H. 2007. A study on integrated regional development of Wuhan Metropolitan area[D]. Wuhan, China: Huzhong University of Science and Technology. [李辉. 2007. 武汉城市圈区域一体化发展研究[D]. 武汉: 华中科技大学.]
[31] Li J F, Liu Y. 2004. An analysis of the international trade from the perspective of new institutional economics. International Economics and Trade Research, 20(2): 11-14. [李景峰, 刘英. 2004. 国际贸易的新制度经济学分析. 国际经贸探索, 20(2): 11-14.]
[32] Li M, Zhang Y L. 2006. Reflection on the economic overcompetition and system innovation in Yangtze River Delta. Journal of Jishou University: Social Sciences Edition, 27(5): 128-133. [李萌, 张佑林. 2006.“长三角”经济过度竞争与制度创新的思考. 吉首大学学报: 社会科学版, 27(5): 128-133.]
[33] Li P, Chen N. 2005. An explanation of the integration of regional economy from the point of neo-institutional economics. Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology: Social Sciences Edition, 7(2): 72-76. [李平, 陈娜. 2005. 区域经济一体化的新制度经济学解释. 哈尔滨工业大学学报: 社会科学版, 7(2): 72-76.]
[34] Li X H. 2007. A theoretical review of economic effect of international regional integration. Information of Economics and Law, 23(3): 50-57. [李欣红. 2007. 国际区域一体化的经济效应分析理论综述. 财经政法资讯, 23(3): 50-57.]
[35] Liang S L, Cheng X J. 2007. A theoretical review of international economic integration. Inquiry into Economic Issues, (1): 40-47. [梁双陆, 程小军. 2007. 国际区域经济一体化理论综述. 经济问题探索, (1): 40-47.]
[36] Linklater A. 1998. The transformation of the political community: Ethical foundations of the Post-Westphalian era. Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press.
[37] Liu C,Wang D F. 2007. Analysis of regional economic integra-tion based on the new institutional economics. Asia-Pacific Economic Review, (2): 27-28. [刘澄, 王东峰. 2007. 区域经济一体化的新制度经济学分析. 亚太经济, (2): 27-28.]
[38] Liu W D.2003. Interdependent relationship between economic globalization and local development: Obligated embeddedness. World Regional Studies, 12(1): 1-9. [刘卫东. 2003. 论全球化与地区发展之间的辩证关系: 被动嵌入. 世界地理研究, 12(1): 1-9.]
[39] Liu W D, Zhen F. 2004. Spatial implications of new information and communication technologies. Acta Geographica Sinica, 59(Suppl.): 67-76. [刘卫东, 甄峰. 信息化对社会经济空间组织的影响研究. 地理学报, 59(增刊): 67-76.]
[40] Martin L W, Wigen K E. 1997. The myth of continents: A critique of metageography. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
[41] Meade J E. 1955. The theory of customs unions. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
[42] Meng Q. 2001a. The study of economic agglomeration under the model of economic integration. Human Geography, 16 (6): 7-11. [孟庆民. 2001a. 一体化条件下的空间经济集聚. 人文地理, 16(6): 7-11.]
[43] Meng Q. 2001b. The concepts and mechanism of regional economic integration. Research on Development, (2): 47-49. [孟庆民. 2001b. 区域经济一体化的概念与机制. 开发研究, (2): 47-49.]
[44] Miao C H, Wei Y H, Lü L C. 2011. New economic geographies. Beijing, China: Science Press. [苗长虹, 魏也华, 吕拉昌. 2011. 新经济地理学. 北京: 科学出版社.]
[45] Nye J S. 1968. Comparative regional integration: Concept and measurement. International Organization, 22(4): 855-880.
[46] O'Loughlin J, van der Wusten H. 1990. Political geography of panregions. Geographical Review, 80(1): 1-20.
[47] Olson M. 1995. The logic of collective action: Public goods and the theory of groups. Chen Y, Guo Y F, Li C X, Trans.. Shanghai, China: SDX Joint Publishing Company. [Olson M. 1995. 集体行动的逻辑. 陈郁, 郭宇峰, 李崇新, 译. 上海: 三联书店.]
[48] Pang X M. 1997a. The conception of regional intergration and related development. Progress in Geography, 16(2): 39-47. [庞效民. 1997a. 区域一体化的理论概念及其发展. 地理科学进展, 16(2): 39-47.]
[49] Pang X M. 1997b. Expanding theoretical basis of regional economic cooperation. Progress in Geography, 16(4): 42-48. [庞效民. 1997b. 区域经济合作的理论基础及其发展. 地理科学进展, 16(4): 42-48.]
[50] Pang X M. 1998. On the basic characteristics of the practice of regionalism. Progress in Geography, 17(2): 42-51.[庞效民. 1998. 区域集团化发展实践的基本特征分析. 地理科学进展, 17(2): 42-51.]
[51] Pollard S. 1974. European economic integration 1815-1970. London: Thames and Hudson.
[52] Puchala D. 1970. International transactions and regional integration. International Organization, 24(4): 732-763.
[53] Qian H X. 2010. The measure of regional economic integration in Yangtze River Delta. Finance and Trade Research, (5): 24-32. [千慧雄. 2010. 长三角区域经济一体化测度. 财贸研究, (5): 24-32.]
[54] Rascdorf A C. 2006. Communicative indicator for the study of regional integration: A critical theory perspective//Lombaerde P D. Assessment and measurement of regional integration. London: Routledge: 52-60.
[55] Robson P. 2001. The economics of international integration. Dai B R, Trans.. Shanghai, China: Shanghai Translation Publishing House. [Robson P. 2001. 国际一体化经济学. 戴炳然, 译. 上海: 上海译文出版社.]
[56] Scott A J. 2001. Globalization and the rise of city-regions. European Planning Studies, 9(7): 813-826.
[57] Sun D B. 2003. A Probe into the dynamic mechanism of regional economic integration in China. International Economics and Trade Research, 19(6): 71-74. [孙大斌. 2003. 由产业发展趋势探讨我国区域经济一体化动力机制. 国际经贸探索, 19(6): 71-74.]
[58] Taylor P J. 2004. World city network: A global urban analysis. London: Routledge.
[59] Telò M. 2001. Globalization, new regionalism and the role of the European union//Telò M. European union and new regionalism: Regional actors and global governance in a post-hegemonic era. London: Ashgate Publishing: 1-20.
[60] Wang L, Liu W D. 2010. Progress in the study of border and border effects issues by economic geographers: Western countries experience and its implications for China. Progress in Geography, 29(5): 601-608. [王亮, 刘卫东. 2010. 西方经济地理学对国家边界及其效应的研究进展, 地理科学进展, 29(5): 601-608.]
[61] Xiao H R. 2002. The evolution of regionalism theories[D]. Beijing, China: Graduate School of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. [肖欢容. 2002. 地区主义理论的历史演进[D]. 北京: 中国社会科学院研究生院.]
[62] Yu L, Jin F J, Wang C J. 2006. The study on pattern of international trade geography. Progress in Geography, 25(5): 112-119. [于良, 金凤君, 王成金. 2006. 国际贸易空间格局特征及其驱动因素, 25(5): 112-119.]
[63] Zhang E Z. 1994. The analysis of trade effect and economic integration. Journal of Nanjing University: Philosophy, Humanities and Social Sciences, (1): 79-88. [张二震. 1994. 论经济一体化及其贸易政策效应. 南京大学学报: 哲学·人文科学·社会科学, (1): 79-88.]
[64] Zhang J X. 2004. Transformation of regional development and planning in the globalization background. Urban Plan-ning Overseas, 19(3): 1-4. [张京祥. 2004. 全球化背景中的区域发展与规划转变. 国外城市规划, 19(3): 1-4.]
[65] Zhang X P, Liu W D. 2003. Impacts of economic globalization on regional development: A preliminary review. Progress in Geography, 22(6): 627-638. [张晓平, 刘卫东. 2003. 全球化、跨国公司投资与地区发展关系研究进展. 地理科学进展, 22(6): 627-638.]
[66] Zhou B J. 1999. The theories, practices and prospective of international economic integration in new era. Shanghai, China: Shanghai People's Publishing House. [周八骏. 1999. 迈向新世纪的国际经济一体化: 理论·实践·前景. 上海: 上海人民出版社.]
[67] Zhou Z H. 2006. Logistic relation of globalization, global urban network and global cities. Social Sciences, (10): 17-27. [周振华. 2006. 全球化、全球城市网络与全球城市的逻辑关系. 社会科学, (10): 17-27.]