基于多重动力机制的集群企业迁移及区域影响——以温州灯具企业迁移中山古镇为例
网络出版日期: 2009-05-25
基金资助
国家自然科学基金重点项目(40535027)
Firm Migration of Clusters in East Coastal Areas of China: A Case Study of Lamp-making Clusters in Wenzhou, Zhejiang
Online published: 2009-05-25
我国沿海发达地区的企业迁移通常被认为是企业优势延伸或再造的扩张型迁移，其动力来自于资源稀缺、要素成本上升、技术升级以及环境规制等多重压力，主要体现比较优势的思维逻辑。选择温州灯具企业迁移中山古镇一例，采取半结构式访谈，透析集群企业迁移的多层面的动力机制。研究表明，发达地区在要素价格上的差距并不显著，不足以导致非空间邻近的、大规模群体式外迁。迫于同质产品竞争的压力，突破核心技术瓶颈的制约成为企业迁移的重要内在动力。开放的地方网络组织能够减少企业外迁的交易成本和潜在风险，地方行业自律机制及政府公共治理产生的正向集聚力或负向离心力，均影响到迁移决策过程。集群企业的迁移路径具有显著的集群指向性，这意味着，基于集体创新能力和集群治理效率的地区竞争优势构成企业迁移的外部推力或拉力。群体迁移短期容易造成迁出地的产业空洞化甚至引致集群衰退，在增强迁入地集群效应的同时，也会对其原有的市场结构和创新环境产生深刻影响。
朱华晟1|王缉慈2|李鹏飞2|李伟1 . 基于多重动力机制的集群企业迁移及区域影响——以温州灯具企业迁移中山古镇为例[J]. 地理科学进展, 2009 , 28(3) : 329 -336 . DOI: 10.11820/dlkxjz.2009.03.002
Firm emigration from the east coastal areas in China is generally explained as spatial expansion of firms，and can be attributed to these factors, such as resource scarcity, rising cost, technology upgrade, and environmental regulations. That point of view apparently follows the logic of comparative advantages. This article takes Wenzhou lamp-making cluster in Zhejiang Province as an example to analyze mechanism of firm migration in clusters. Based on the semi-structured depth interviews in Guzhen Town, Guangdong Province - one of the major immigration destination of Wenzhou firms - with local authorities, industrial associations, native firms, and Wenzhou firms, the article demonstrates that the increase of local resource price and the limitation of accessible space in Wenzhou can not be fully explained as powerful driven forces, while scarcity of core technology and deterioration of business environment actually push firms out. Furthermore, network organizations reduce transaction costs and potential risks of firm migration from Wenzhou to Guzhen and strengthen their bargaining power in the immigration area. Besides, such migration is typically cluster-oriented, which means that the competitive advantage based on the collective creativity and governance efficiency drive cluster firms to relocate.Firm emigration to some extent weakens the advantages of Wenzhou cluster. As far as Guzhen Town, firm immigration increases the cluster effects on one hand, and exerts some influence on the local innovation system on the other hand.
[1] Pellenbarg P, Wissen L, D J. Firm migration. McCann P.Industrial Location Economics. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2002:110－148.
[2] 王珺.珠三角应实施"多向度"突围
[EB/OL].http://business.sohu.com，2008-10-30.
[3] 吕文栋，朱华晟.浙江产业集群的动力机制: 基于企业家的视角.中国工业经济，2005(4)：86－93.
[4] 王缉慈，李鹏飞. 珠三角产业面临"空心化"？中国报导，2008(5)：48－49.
[5] 黄冬梅，杜伟锦. 浙江民营企业迁移的理论动因.经济论坛，2006(5)：19－21.
[6] 张华，梁进社.产业空间集聚及其效应的研究进展. 地理科学进展，2007，26(2)： 14－24.
[7] Nakosteen R, Zimmer M. Determinants of regional migration by manufacturing firms. Economic Inquiry, 1987, 25(2): 351-362.
[8] Mariotti I. Firm relocation and regional policy: A focus on Italy, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom
[EB/OL], http://dissertations.ub.rug.nl/FILES/faculties/rw/2005/i.mariotti/titlecon.pdf, 2008-11-15.
[9] Pellenbarg P. Firm migration in the Netherlands. Paper for the 45th European Regional Science Association Congress, August 2005, Amsterdam.
[10] 鲁德银. 企业家行为、企业迁移、产业集群与农村城镇化政策. 财经研究，2007,33(11)：82－91.
[11] Townroe M. Rationality in industrial location decisions. Urban Studies, 1991,28(3): 383-392.
[12] Pen C, Pellenbarg P. Central, provincial, and municipal government policy in the Netherlands and the impact on firm migrations. Paper for the 38th European Regional Science Association Congress, August 1998, Vienna.
[13] Dijk J, Pellenbarg H. Firm relocation decisions in the Netherlands: an ordered logic approach. The 39th European Congress of the Regional Science Association, August 23-27:1999.
[14] Dicken P, Lloyd E. Location in space: Theoretical perspectives in economic geography. New York: Harper & Row, 1990: 20.
[15] 朱华晟.浙江产业群—产业网络、成长轨迹与发展动力. 杭州：浙江大学出版社，2003: 31－33.
[16] 魏后凯，白玫.中国上市公司总部迁移现状及特征分析.中国工业经济，2008(10)：1－13.
[17] 傅晓霞，魏后凯，吴利学.城市工业搬迁的动因、方式和效果-以北京市为例. 经济管理，2007，29（21）：66－71.
[18] 黄继忠.论乡镇工业的集聚. 中国工业经济，1997(5)：36－38.
[19] 项后军.外资企业的迁移及其根植性问题研究： 以台资企业为例.浙江社会科学，2004(3)：67－72.
[20] 李王鸣，朱珊，王纯彬.民营企业迁移扩张现象调查： 以浙江省乐清市为例. 经济问题，2004(9)：30－32.
[21] 徐金发，张宏，江青虎.总部经济对区域经济发展的积极意义: 基于对企业搬迁过程和效果的剖析.技术经济，2006，25(7)：45－47.
[22] 张纯，王敬甯，陈平.地方创意环境和实体空间对城市文化创意活动的影响: 以北京市南锣鼓巷为例. 地理研究，2008，27(2)：439－448.
[23] 周尚意，沈小平.北京美术产业对地方文化的嵌入性程度分析.人文地理，2008(2)：26－42.
[24] 郑海华.灯具业，璀璨背后的乡恋
[EB/OL].www.wzdaily.com.cn，2003-01-02.
[25] 中国建材网.照明电器向集中化专业化统一化发展
[EB/OL].www. bmlink .com，2005-7-21.
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |