区域可持续发展评价:进展与展望

doi:10.11820/dlkxjz.2002.03.006

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 可持续发展的评价是目前可持续发展研究的热点和前沿。当前评价可持续发展的单项指标和指标体系在指标与可持续性的关系、指标权重的选择、指标的定量化、可持续性的总体判别方法、资本替代性与替代速度、指标阈值的确定等方面具有不同的局限性 ,这也是可持续发展评价的主要难点。可持续发展的评价必然要落实到不同尺度的空间地理单元上 ,区域发展是评价的对象 ,因而可持续发展的评价必然具有显著的区域性 ,不同区域的评价指标或指标体系必然会有所不同。社会、经济与人口的发展是人类社会发展的主要目标 ,而发展的可持续性依赖于自然环境的质量 ,包括自然资源的再生或替代、生命支持系统与生物多样性的维持或改善。据此 ,论文构建了区域可持续发展评价的理论框架和发展——可持续性二维评价坐标体系 ,并提出了“自上而下”和“自下而上”的指标遴选方法。

关键词: 可持续发展, 理论框架, 评价, 指标体系

Abstract: The assessment of sustainability is a critical issue and a frontier in the research area of sustainable development. The paper reviews the current methodologies and theories, and identifys main difficulties and probable solutions, such as the relationship between sustainability and indicators, weighting of indicators, quantifying of indicators, substitution between different capitals, and definition of thresholds. It argues that the assessment of sustainability should be focused on certain geographical area and would be stamped with the brand of a region. Thus the indicators of sustainable development in different regions vary remarkably. It points out that socio economic development, consisting of economic, social and demographic improvements, is the main objective of regional development, but its sustainability depends on the support capability of environment, including the life support system, resource, and biodiversity. Thus, the development and its sustainability can be regarded as a two coordinate axes of the reference frame to assess regional development. Based on the methodology of barometer of sustainability, sustainability can be pictured in four different quadrants in this reference frame. Moreover, it puts forward the methodology for indicator selecting.

Key words: Assessment, Barometer of Sustainability, Indicator System, Regional Sustainable Development

中图分类号:

李利锋, 郑度. 区域可持续发展评价:进展与展望[J]. 地理科学进展, 2002, 21(3): 237-248.

LI Li feng, ZHENG Du . An Assessment of Regional Sustainable Development: Progress and Perspectives[J]. PROGRESS IN GEOGRAPHY, 2002, 21(3): 237-248.

参考文献

[1] 　T rzyna T C(ed s.).A Su stainab le W o rld:D efin ing and M easu ring Su stainab le D evelopm en t[M].L ondon:Earth scan,1995.17.

[2] 　Cobb C W,R ixfo rd C.L esson s L earned from the H isto ry of Social Ind icato rs[M].San F rancisco:R edefin ingP rog ress,1998.

[3] 　L iverm an D M,H an son M E,B row n B J et al.Global su stainab ility:tow ard m easu rem en t[J].E nv ironm en ta lM anag em en t,1988,12(2):133-143.

[4] 　Peter H ard i,T errence Zdan.T he Belllag io p rincip les fo r assessm en t[A].In:Peter H ard i and T errence Zdan(ed s.).A ssessing su stainab le developm en t:P rincip les in p ractice[C].W inn ip eg,Canada:In ternational In stitu teof Su stainab le D evelopm en t,1997.

[5] 　Cobb C.T he Index of Su stainab le Econom ic W elfare[A].In:D aly H E,Cobb J B(ed s.).Fo r the Comm on Good[C].Bo ston:Beacon P ress,1989.401-455.

[6] 　Cobb C,H alstead T.T he Genu ine P rog ress Ind icato r[M].San F rancisco:R edefin ing P rog ress,1994.

[7] 　Stockhamm er E,Hoch reiter H,O berm eyr B et al.T he index of su stainab le econom ic w elfare as an alternative toGD P in m easu ring econom ic w elfare.T he resu lts of the Austrian(revised)ISEW calcu lation 1955-1992[J].E colog ica l E conom ics,1997,21:19-24.

[8] 　Row e J,A n ielsk iM.Genu ine p rog ress ind icato r 1998:Execu tive summ ary[M OL].h ttp:www.rp rog ress.o rgp ub s gp i1998 gp i1998-execsum.h tm l,1999-0922.

[9] 　H ard i P,Barg S.M easu ring Su stainab le D evelopm en t:R eview ing of Cu rren t P ractice[M].O ttaw a:Indu stryCanada,1997.

[10] 　H ick s John R ichard.V alue and Cap ital[M].O xfo rd:C larendon P ress,1946.

[11] 　[英]皮尔斯(Pearce D W),沃福德(W arfo rd J J)著.张世秋等译.张坤民校.世界无末日:经济学,环境与可持续发展[M].北京:中国财政经济出版,1996.

[12] 　T he W o rld Bank.M on ito ring Environm en tal P rog ress:A R epo rt on W o rk in P rog ress[M].N ew Yo rk:T heW o rld Bank,1995.

[13] 　T he W o rld Bank.Exp and ing the M easu re of W ealth:Ind icato rs of Environm en tally Su stainab le D evelopm en t[M].N ew Yo rk:T he W o rld Bank,1997.

[14] 　D aly H.O n W ilfred Beckerm an’s critique of su stainab le developm en t[J].E nv iron.V a lues,1995,4:50.

[15] 　Berkes F,Fo lke C.Investing in the cu ltu ral cap ital fo r su stainab le u se of natu re cap ital[A].In:J an sson A,H amm er M,Fo lke C et al(ed s.).Investing in N atu ral Cap ital:T he Ecolog ical Econom ics A pp roach toSu stainab le D evelopm en t[C].W ash ing ton D.C.:Island P ress,1995.

[16] 　D ale J am ieson.Su stainab ility and beyond[J].E colog ica l E conom ics,1998,24:183-192.

[17] 　U ND P.H um an D evelopm en t R epo rt,1990,1991,1994,1995,1997[M].N ew Yo rk:O xfo rd U n iversity P ress.

[18] 　Sagar A D,N ajam A.T he hum an developm en t index:a critical review[J].E colog ica l E conom ics,1998,25:249-264.

[19] 　Yo sh ih iko W ada.T he m yth of’su stainab le developm en t’:T he eco log ical foo tp rin t of J ap anese con sum p tion.D issertation D].V ancouver,B.C.:Schoo l of Comm un ity and R eg ional P lann ing,T he U n iversity of B ritishCo lum b ia,Canada,1999.

[20] 　M ath is W ackernagel,W illiam E(R ees.).O u r Eco log ical Foo tp rin t:R educing H um an Im p act on the Earth[M].Gab rio la Island.B.C.,Canada:N ew Society Pub lishers,1996.

[21] 　M ath is W ackernagel.Eco log ical foo tp rin t and app rop riated carrying cap acity:a too l fo r p lann ing tow ardsu stainab ility.[D issertation D].V ancouver,B.C.:Schoo l of Comm un ity and R eg ional P lann ing,T he U n iversityof B ritish Co lum b ia,Canada,1994.

[22] 　W illiam E(R ees.).R evisiting carrying cap acity:area2based ind icato rs of su stainab ility[J].P op u la tion andE nv ironm en t:a J ou rna l of In terna tiona l In terd iscip lina ry S tud ies,1997,17(3).

[23] 　M ath is W ackernagel.W hat w e u se and w hat w e have:Eco log ical Foo tp rin t and Eco log ical Cap acity[M OL].h ttp:www.rp rog ress.o rg.1999.

[24] 　李利锋,成升魁.生态占用——衡量可持续发展的新指标[J].自然资源学报,2001,15(4):375-382.

[25] 　徐中民,张志强,程国栋.甘肃省1998年生态足迹计算与分析[J].地理学报,2000,55(5):607-616.

[26] 　牛文元,持续发展导论[M].北京:科学出版社,1994.

[27] 　H u T ao.Eco2value and su stainab le developm en t[A].In:W ang R u song,Zhao J ingzhu,O uyang Zh iyuan(ed s.).H um an System s Eco logy[C].Beijing:Ch ina Science&T echno logy P ress,1991.235-236.

[28] 　V ictou sek P,Eh rlich,P,En rlich,A et al.H um an app rop riation of the p roducts of p ho to syn thesis[J].B ioscience,1986,34:368-373.

[29] 　H aberl H.环境指示因子——净初级生产量的人类占有:对可持续发展的影响[J].A M B IO人类环境杂志,1997,27(3):139-142.

[30] 　O ECD.Environm en tal Ind icato rs:O ECD Co re Set[M].Paris:O ECD,1994.

[31] 　O ECD.Tow ard s Su stainab le D evelopm en t:Environm en tal Ind icato rs[M].Paris:O ECD,1998.

[32] 　H amm ond A.A d riaan se A,Rodenbu rg E et al.Environm en tal Ind icato rs:A System A pp roach to M easu ring andR epo rting on Environm en tal Po licy Perfo rm ance in the Con tex t of Su stainab le D evelopm en t[M].N ew Yo rk:W o rld R esou rces In stitu te,1995.

[33] 　A d riaan se A.Environm en tal Po licy Perfo rm ance Ind icato rs.A Study on the D evelopm en t of Ind icato rs fo rEnvironm en tal Po licy in the N etherland s[M].T he H ague:Sdu U itgeverij Kon ing inneg rach t,1993.

[34] 　N ajam A.A ssessing p rog ress tow ard su stainab ility in develop ing coun tries[A].In:H ard i P,Zdan T(ed s.).A ssessing su stainab le developm en t:P rincip les in p ractice[C].W inn ip eg:In ternational In stitu te fo r Su stainab leD evelopm en t,1997.

[35] 　Donella M eadow s.Ind icato rs and Info rm ation System s fo r Su stainab le D evelopm en t:A R epo rt to the BalatonGroup[M].T he Su stainab ility In stitu te.

[36] 　D aly H E.Tow ard a Steady2State Econom y[M].San F rancisco:W.H.F reem an and Com p any,1973.8.

[37] 　IU CN,U N EP,WW F.Caring fo r the Earth:a Strategy fo r Su stainab le L iving[M].N ew Yo rk:IU CN,U N EP,WW F,1992.

[38] 　毛汉英.山东省可持续发展指标体系初步研究[J].地理研究,1996,15(4):16-23.

[39] 　王合生,虞孝感.我国发达地区可持续发展指标体系及其评价[J].经济地理,1997,17(4):21-25.

[40] 　刘求实,沈红.区域可持续法指标体系与评价方法研究[J].中国人口,资源与环境,1997,7(4):60-64.

[41] 　薛东辉,窦贻俭.仪征市可持续发展指标体系研究[J].城市环境与城市生态,1998,11(1):32-35.

[42] 　秦振耀,徐铭杰.区域持续发展的指标研究[J].地理学报,1998,53(2):149-155.

[43] 　郝晓辉.可持续发展指标体系初探[J].世界环境,1996(1):11-13.

[44] 　赵景柱.资源利用与持续发展研究[博士论文D].北京:中国科学院生态环境研究中心,1991.

[45] 　成升魁.中国可持续发展判别及指标体系构建[A].见:秦大河主编.可持续发展战略探索[C].北京:中国环境科学出版社,1998.129.

[46] 　吴越明,郎东锋,张子衍,张翼.环境——经济系统协调度模型及其指标体系[J].中国人口,资源与环境,1996,6(2).

[47] 　牛文元.自然灾害管理系统[J].科学通报,1990(17):132021323.

[48] 　郑度.面向建设实践,促进地理学发展[J].地理科学进展,1997,16(1):6-10.

[49] 　毛汉英.县域经济和社会与人口,资源,环境协调发展研究[J].经济地理,1991,46(4).

[50] 　马世骏,王如松.社会-经济-自然复合生态系统[J].生态学报,1984,4(1).

[51] 　孙鸿烈.资源科学研究的现在与未来[J].资源科学,1998,20(1):3-12.

[52] 　IU CN,Barom eter of su stainab ility[M OL].h ttp:www.iucn.o rg them es eval eng lish barom eter h tm,A ugu st 10,1999.