流域生态补偿研究现状及关键问题剖析

doi:10.11820/dlkxjz.2012.04.001

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 在流域,因竞争性用水导致上下游之间、人类发展与生态环境之间的矛盾日益尖锐,急需建立健全流域生态补偿机制.通过对国内外流域生态补偿研究进展进行梳理,发现流域生态补偿研究主要集中在流域尺度的补偿计划实施评价、补偿尺度的选择、补偿标准的测算、生态补偿与减少贫困关系、流域生态补偿的空间差异性等方面,其关键问题在于生态补偿主体和对象的确定以及补偿标准的制定;研究认为通过流域断面水量水质及相关利益分析方法来确定补偿主体和对象;而补偿标准则以流域上下游生态损益、机会成本、居民支付意愿分别作为补偿上限、参考值和下限来综合确定.以此为基础,构建流域多种生态要素、多元主体间的流域生态补偿机制研究框架.最后,就流域生态补偿机制构建过程中有待解决的科学问题进行了讨论.

关键词: 补偿标准, 补偿主体和对象, 流域, 生态补偿, 生态服务

Abstract: In a watershed, competitive water use in upstream and downstream causes a conflict between development of human beings and eco-environment. It is high time to establish mechanism of payments for ecosystem services (PES). Domestic and foreign researches on PES in watersheds mainly focus on assessment on PES implementation, choice of compensation scale, calculation of compensation standard, relationship between PES and poverty reduction, and spatial differentiation of PES. The key issues are how to make eco-compensation standard and how to realize the beneficial owner recuperation. Compensation bodies and compensation objects are defined by analysis of stakeholders and water quantity and quality between upstream and downstream. Meanwhile, maximum standard, minimum standard and reference standard of eco-compensation are determined by calculating ecological profit and loss from upstream to downstream, opportunity cost and willingness to pay (WTP). Furthermore, PES mechanism of multi-level, multi-subject and multi-factor is established. Finally, difficulties are analyzed during the construction of PES mechanism in watersheds.

Key words: compensation bodies and compensation objects, eco-compensation standard, ecosystem service, PES (payments for ecosystem services), watershed

乔旭宁, 杨永菊, 杨德刚. 流域生态补偿研究现状及关键问题剖析[J]. 地理科学进展, 2012, 31(4): 395-402.

QIAO Xuning, YANG Yongju, YANG Degang. Review of Payments for Ecosystem Services and the Key Issues in a Watershed[J]. PROGRESS IN GEOGRAPHY, 2012, 31(4): 395-402.

参考文献

[1] 王让会, 游先祥. 西部干旱区内陆河流域脆弱生态环境研究进展: 以新疆塔里木河流域为例. 地球科学进展,2000, 16(1): 39-44.
[2] 程国栋, 肖洪浪, 徐中民, 等. 中国西北内陆河水问题及其应对策略: 以黑河流域为例. 冰川冻土, 2006, 28(3):406-413.
[3] 陈亚宁, 崔旺诚, 李卫红, 等. 塔里木河的水资源利用与生态保护. 地理学报, 2003, 58(2): 215-222.
[4] 秦艳红, 康慕谊. 国内外生态补偿现状及其完善措施.自然资源学报, 2007, 22(4): 557-566.
[5] Coase D. The problem of social cost. Journal of Law andEconomics, 1960, 3(1): 1-44.
[6] 靳乐山,李小云,左停, 等. 生态环境服务付费的国际经验及其对中国的启示. 生态经济, 2007(12): 156-163.
[7] Gowell R. Stretching the limits: Environmental compensation,habitat creation and sustainable development .Trans. Inst. Br. Geogr., 1997, 22(3): 292-306.
[8] Merlo M, Briales E R. Public goods and externalitieslinked to Mediterranean forests: Economic nature andpolicy. Land Use Policy, 2000, 17(3): 197-208.
[9] Murray B C, Abt R C. Estimating price compensation requirementsfor eco-certified forestry. Ecological Economics,2001, 36(1): 149-163.
[10] Landell-Mills N, Porras I. Silver bullet or fools'gold? Aglobal review of markets for forest environmental servicesand their impact on the poor. London: International Institutefor Environment and Development (IIED), 2002.
[11] Warner K, Huang M D, Middleton. Financial Incentivesto Communities for Stewardship of Environmental Resources:Feasibility Study. Report prepared by Winrockfor USAID, 2004.
[12] Rosa H, Kandel S, Dimas L. Compensation for environmentalservices and rural communities: Lessons from theAmericas. International Forestry Review, 2004, 61(2):187-194.
[13] Kosoy N, Martinez-Tuna M, Muradian R, et al. Paymentsfor environmental services in watersheds: Insights from acomparative study of three cases in Central America. EcologicalEconomics, 2007, 61: 446-455.
[14] Pagiola S, Arcenas A, Platais G, et al. Can payments forenvironmental services help reduce poverty? An explorationof the issues and the evidence to date from LatinAmerica.World Development, 2005, 33(2): 237-253.
[15] Zbinden, Lee D. Paying for environmental services: Ananalysis of participation in Costa Rica's PSA program.World Development, 2005, 33(2): 255-272.
[16] Engel S, Pagiola S. Designing payments for environmentalservices in theory and practice: An overview of the issues.Ecological Economics, 2008, 65(4): 663-674.
[17] Wunder S. Payments for Environmental Services: Somenuts and bolts. Occasional Paper No.42. CIFOR, Bogor,2005.
[18] Reddy V R. Costs of resource depletion externalities: Astudy of groundwater overexploitation in AndhraPradesh, India. Environment and Development Economics,2005, 10(4): 533-556.
[19] Shiferaw B. Watershed externalities, shifting croppingpatterns and groundwater depletion in Indian semi-aridvillages: The effect of alternative water pricing policies.Ecological Economics, 2008, 67(2): 327-340.
[20] Wünscher T, Engel S, Wunder S. Spatial targeting of paymentsfor environmental services: A tool for boostingconservation benefits. Ecological Economics, 2008, 65(4): 822-833.
[21] 戴其文, 赵雪雁. 生态补偿机制中若干关键科学问题:以甘南藏族自治州草地生态系统为例. 地理学报,2010, 65(4): 494-506.
[22] 张惠远, 刘桂环. 我国流域生态补偿机制设计. 环境保护, 2006(10A): 50-54.
[23] 郑海霞, 张陆彪. 流域生态服务补偿定量标准研究. 环境保护, 2006(1): 42-46.
[24] 程艳军. 中国流域生态服务补偿模式研究: 以浙江省金华江流域为例[D]. 中国农科院, 2006.
[25] 杨佩国. 潮白河流域生态补偿机制研究[D]. 中国科学院研究生院, 2007.
[26] 刘玉龙. 生态补偿与流域生态共建共享. 北京: 中国水利水电出版社, 2007.
[27] 郑海霞. 中国流域生态服务补偿机制与政策: 以4 个典型流域为例[D]. 中国农业科学院, 2006.
[28] 中国环境与发展国际合作委员会生态补偿机制课题组. 流域生态补偿机制. 环境保护, 2007(10A): 53-54.
[29] 陈兆开. 淮河流域水资源生态补偿制度问题研究. 安徽农业科学, 2007, 35(24): 7599-7600.
[30] 郑海霞, 张陆彪. 金华江流域生态服务补偿机制及其政策建议. 资源科学, 2006, 28(5): 30-35.
[31] 甄霖, 刘雪林, 李芬, 等. 脆弱生态区生态系统服务消费与生态补偿研究: 进展与挑战. 资源科学, 2010, 32(5):797-803.
[32] 李文华, 刘某承. 关于中国生态补偿机制建设的几点思考. 资源科学, 2010, 32(5): 791-796.
[33] 孙新章, 周海林, 张新民. 中国全面建立生态补偿制度的基础与阶段推进论. 资源科学, 2009, 31(8):1349-1354.
[34] Costanza R, d'Arge R, de-Groot R, et al. The value ofthe world's ecosystem services and natural capital. EcologicalEconomics, 1997, 25(1): 3-15.
[35] Pimentel D, Wilson C, McCullum C, et al. Economic andenvironmental benefits of biodiversity. Bioscience, 1997,47(11): 747-757.
[36] Turner R K, Daily G C. The ecosystem services frameworkand natural capital conservation. Environ ResourceEcon, 2008, 39(1): 25-35.
[37] 侯元兆, 吴水荣. 森林生态服务价值评价与补偿研究综述. 世界林业研究, 2005, 18(3): 1-5.
[38] 李金昌, 姜文来, 靳乐山, 等. 生态价值论. 重庆: 重庆大学出版社, 1999.
[39] 欧阳志云, 王如松, 赵景柱. 生态系统服务功能及其生态经济价值评价. 应用生态学报, 1999, 10(5): 635-640.
[40] Xiong Ying, Wang Kelin. Eco-compensation effects ofthe wetland recovery in Dongting Lake area. J.Geogr.Sci., 2010, 20(3): 389-405.
[41] 谢高地, 鲁春霞, 冷允法, 等. 青藏高原生态资产的价值评估. 自然资源学报, 2003, 18(2): 189-195.
[42] 张志强, 徐中民, 王建, 等. 黑河流域生态系统服务的价值. 冰川冻土, 2001, 23(4): 360-365.
[43] 黄湘. 塔里木河流域生态系统服务功能价值研究[D]. 中国科学院研究生院, 2007.
[44] Wu Y, Jie C, Bin X, et al. Ecosystem service value assessmentfor constructed wetlands: A case study in Hangzhou,China. Ecological Economics, 2008, 68(1):116-125.
[45] Groot R, Wilson M A, Boumans R, et al. A typology forthe classification description and valuation of ecosystemfunctions, goods and service. Ecological Economics,2002, 41(3): 393-408.
[46] 范小杉, 高吉喜, 温文. 生态资产空间流转及价值评估模型初探. 环境科学研究, 2007, 20(5): 160-164.
[47] 乔旭宁, 杨永菊, 杨德刚, 等.生态服务功能价值空间转移评价: 以渭干河流域为例. 中国沙漠, 2011, 31(4):1008-1014.
[48] 杨光梅, 李文华, 闵庆文, 等. 生态系统服务价值评估研究进展. 生态学报, 2006, 26(1): 205-212.
[49] 俞海, 任勇. 流域生态补偿机制的关键问题分析: 以南水北调中线水源涵养区为例. 资源科学, 2007, 29(2):28-33.
[50] Davis R K. Recreation planning as all economic problem. Natural Resources Journal, 1963,3: 239-249.
[51] Greenley D A, Walsh R G, Young R A, et al. EconomicBenefits of Improved Water Quality: Public Perceptionsof Option and Preservation Values. Boulder, Colo.: WestviewPress, 1982.
[52] Loomis J, Kent P, Strange L, et al. Measuring the totaleconomic value of restoring ecosystem services in an impairedriver basin: Results from a contingent valuationsurvey. Ecological Economics, 2000, 33(1): 103-117.
[53] 张志强, 徐中民, 程国栋, 等.黑河流域张掖地区生态系统服务恢复的条件价值评估. 生态学报, 2002, 22(6):885-892.
[54] Xu Z M, Cheng G D, Zhang Z Q, et al. Applying contingentvaluation in China to measure the total economicvalue of restoring ecosystem services in Ejina region.Ecological Economics, 2003, 44(2): 345-358.
[55] 赵雪雁, 董霞, 范君君, 等. 甘南黄河水源补给区生态补偿方式的选择. 冰川冻土, 2010, 32 (1): 204-210.
[56] 乔旭宁. 渭干河流域生态补偿机制研究[D]. 北京: 中国科学院研究生院, 2009.
[57] Mitchell D C, Carson R T. Using Surveys to Value PublicGoods: The Contingent Valuation Method. WashingtonDC: Resources for the Future, 1989.
[58] Loomis J, Brown T, Lucero B, et al. Improving validityexperiments of contingent valuation methods: Results of efforts to reduce the disparity of hypothetical and actualwillingness to pay. Land Econ, 1996, 72(4): 450-61.
[59] Brown T C, Gregory R. Why the WTP-WTA disparitymatters. Ecological Economics, 1999, 28(3): 323-335.
[60] Loomis J B, Walsh R G. Recreation Economic Decisions:Comparing Benefits and Costs. 2nd ed. Pennsylvania:Venture Publishing Inc., 1997.
[61] 熊鹰, 王克林, 蓝万炼. 洞庭湖区湿地恢复的生态补偿效应评估. 地理学报, 2004, 59(5): 772-780.
[62] Castro R, Tattenbach F, Gamez L, et al. The costa ricanexperience with market instruments to mitigate climatechange and conserve biodiversity. Environmental Monitoringand Assessment, 2000, 61(1): 75-92.
[63] 赵翠薇, 王世杰. 生态补偿效益、标准—国际经验及对我国的启示. 地理研究, 2010, 29(4): 597-606.
[64] 美国国家研究院重新发现地理学委员会. 重新发现地理学与科学和社会的新关联. 黄润华, 译. 北京: 学苑出版社, 2002.
[65] 叶亚平. 复合生态系统水生态服务功能评价及调控方法研究[D]. 北京: 中国科学院研究生院, 2004.