基于女性主义地理学视角的家庭暴力研究进展——超越公私二分法

doi:10.18306/dlkxjz.2020.01.014

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

人文地理学者通过家透视生活空间中的社会现象,西方人文地理学文化转向与女性主义研究兴起后,家庭暴力成为学者们关注的对象。在女性主义社会批判特征和地理学空间视角的双重影响下,女性主义地理学家着眼女性的空间经历及情感体验,聚焦女性在家庭中的暴力问题。论文首先介绍“家庭暴力”的概念和公私二分法,指出其中的空间隐蔽性,据此引入女性主义地理学的研究路径,通过分析家庭空间的意义建构,以及容忍家庭暴力存在的更广泛的地理环境,超越空间的公私二分法探讨家庭暴力。基于对国外相关研究的梳理,归纳出家庭、社区/邻里、国家和全球3种尺度分析家庭暴力的地理研究。通过物质、功能、象征维度的家庭空间性分析揭示性别权力在空间上对女性的控制和压迫;运用物质决定论逻辑和社会-文化逻辑2种视角解读家庭暴力存续的社区环境特征及其内在对女性的政策和制度排斥;分析家庭暴力与恐怖主义、军事战争的联系,将家庭暴力议题推向政治地理领域。

关键词: 家庭暴力, 公私二分法, 女性主义, 尺度

Abstract:

Human geographers gain insights into social phenomena through home. Domestic violence has become a research object along with the cultural turn in Western human geography and the rise of feminist studies. Under the dual influence of feminist social criticism and the spatial perspective of geography, feminist geographers focus on women's spatial and emotional experiences, unfolding the violence against women in the home. Starting with the introduction of the concept of "domestic violence" and the public/private dichotomy, this article points out the spatial concealment of domestic violence and introduces the research path of domestic violence issue in feminist geography, that is, to discuss domestic violence beyond the public/private dichotomy of space by examining the meaning construction of home as private space and the broader geographical environment for tolerating the existence of domestic violence. Based on the review of related international research, this article summarizes feminist geographic research of domestic violence on three scales: home, community/neighborhood, and global and national. Following the scale logic, this article concludes the findings of academic significance and provides insights on the trend of future geographic research of domestic violence issue. The implicit assumptions of home within analyses of domestic violence require further examination. The analysis of home in material, functional, and symbolic dimensions reveals the spatial control and oppression on women. The two perspectives of material determinism logic and sociocultural logic provide insights into the characteristics of community environment in which domestic violence persists and their inherent policy and institutional exclusion to women. The research on the connections between domestic violence and terrorism and warfare reflects that violence on the micro scale intertwined with larger (geopolitical) processes, which can remap the debate about safety in political geography.

Key words: domestic violence, public/private dichotomy, feminism, scale

肖鸿元, 汪明峰. 基于女性主义地理学视角的家庭暴力研究进展——超越公私二分法[J]. 地理科学进展, 2020, 39(1): 143-152.

XIAO Hongyuan, WANG Mingfeng. Beyond the public/private dichotomy: The study of domestic violence in feminist geography[J]. PROGRESS IN GEOGRAPHY, 2020, 39(1): 143-152.

图/表 1

参考文献 85

[1]	Blunt A, Varley A . Geographies of home[J]. Cultural Geographies, 2004,11(1):3-6.
[2]	丁传标, 赵永琪, 陶伟 . 城市化进程中家屋空间重构的过程、内容与逻辑: 以广州珠村为例[J]. 地理科学, 2017,37(9):1326-1336.
	[ Ding Chuanbiao, Zhao Yongqi, Tao Wei . The reconstruction of household of Zhucun in Guangzhou in the process of the rapid urbanization. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2017,37(9):1326-1336. ]
[3]	Home Office . Criminal statistics [R]. London, UK: HMSO, 1998.
[4]	Black M C, Basile K C, Breiding M J , et al. The national intimate partner and sexual violence survey (NISVS): 2010 summary report [R]. Atlanta, GA: National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2011.
[5]	董纯朴 . 中国家暴犯罪防控研究[J]. 犯罪研究, 2016(3):17-30.
	[ Dong Chunpu . Research on the prevention and control of domestic violent crimes in China. Chinese Criminology Review, 2016(3):17-30. ]
[6]	Springer S . Violence sits in places? Cultural practice, neoliberal rationalism, and virulent imaginative geographies[J]. Political Geography, 2011,30:90-98.
[7]	诺克斯 P, 平奇 S. 城市社会地理学导论 [M]. 柴彦威, 张景秋, 等, 译. 北京: 商务印书馆, 2005: 288-290.
	[ Knox P, Pinch S. Urban social geography: An introduction. Translated by Chai Yanwei, Zhang Jingqiu, et al. Beijing, China: The Commercial Press, 2005: 288-290. ]
[8]	Pain R . Seismologies of emotion: Fear and activism during domestic violence[J]. Social & Cultural Geography, 2014,15(2):127-150.
[9]	Swan S C, Gambone L J, Caldwell J E , et al. A review of research on women's use of violence with male intimate partners[J]. Violence & Victims, 2008,23(3):301-314.
[10]	Felson R B, Messner S F, Hoskin A W , et al. Reasons for reporting and not reporting domestic violence to the police[J]. Criminology, 2002,40(3):617-647.
[11]	Johnson M P, Ferraro K J . Research on domestic violence in the 1990s: Making distinctions[J]. Journal of Marriage and Family, 2000,62(4):948-963.
[12]	Bonnin D . Claiming spaces, changing places: Political violence and women's protests in Kwazulu-Natal[J]. Journal of Southern African Studies, 2000,26(2):301-316.
[13]	Walby S, Towers J . Untangling the concept of coercive control: Theorizing domestic violent crime[J]. Criminology & Criminal Justice, 2018,18(1):7-28.
[14]	Dobash R P, Dobash R E, Wilson M , et al. The myth of sexual symmetry in marital violence[J]. Social Problems, 1992,39(1):71-91.
[15]	Stark E . Do violent acts equal abuse? Resolving the gender parity/asymmetry dilemma[J]. Sex Roles, 2010,62(3-4):201-211.
[16]	Straus M A . Measuring intrafamily conflict and violence[J]. Journal of Marriage and the Family, 1979,41(1):75-88.
[17]	黄列 . 家庭暴力: 从国际到国内的应对(上)[J]. 环球法律评论, 2002(1):104-114.
	[ Huang Lie . Domestic violence: Response from international to domestic (I). Global Law Review, 2002(1):104-114. ]
[18]	Kim S A . Reconstructing family privacy[J]. Hastings Law Journal, 2006,57(3):557-600.
[19]	Chinkin C . Violence against women: The international legal response[J]. Gender & Development, 1995,3(2):23-28.
[20]	Bourlet A. Police intervention in marital violence [M]. Milton Keynes, Buckingham, UK: Open University Press, 1990.
[21]	Avakame E F, Fyfe J J . Differential police treatment of male-on-female spousal violence: Additional evidence on the leniency journal[J]. Violence against Women, 2001,7(1):22-45.
[22]	Reingardiene J . Dilemmas in private/public discourse: Contexts for gender-based violence against women in Lithuania[J]. Journal of Baltic Studies, 2003,34(3):354-368.
[23]	Wright C, Jaggar G. End of century, end of family? Shifting discourses of family 'crisis' [C]// Wright C, Jaggar G. Changing family values. London, UK: Routledge, 1999: 17-37.
[24]	Watson S . Definitions of homelessness: A feminist perspective[J]. Critical Social Policy, 1984,4(11):60-73.
[25]	封丹, 李鹏, 朱竑 . 国外“家”的地理学研究进展及启示[J]. 地理科学进展, 2015,34(7):809-817.
	[ Feng Dan, Li Peng, Zhu Hong . Progress in geographic studies on "home" and implications for China. Progress in Geography, 2015,34(7):809-817. ]
[26]	Goldsack L. A harem in a heartless world? Women and domestic violence [C]// Chapman T, Hockey J. Ideal homes? Social change and domestic life. London, UK: Routledge, 1999: 121-132.
[27]	Brickell C . Heroes and invaders: Gay and lesbian pride parades and the public/private distinction in New Zealand media accounts[J]. Gender Place and Culture, 2000,7(2):163-178.
[28]	McDowell L . Gender, identity and place: Understanding feminist geographies [M]. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press, 1999: 72-73.
[29]	Sweet E L . Carceral feminism: Linking the state, intersectional bodies, and the dichotomy of place[J]. Dialogues in Human Geography, 2016,6(2):202-205.
[30]	Holmes C . Destabilizing homonormativity and the public/private dichotomy in North American lesbian domestic violence discourses[J]. Gender, Place & Culture, 2009,16(1):77-95.
[31]	Abraham J . Veiling and the production of gender and space in a town in North India: A Critique of the public/private dichotomy[J]. Indian Journal of Gender Studies, 2010,17(2):191-222.
[32]	Pain R . Space, sexual violence and social control: Integrating geographical and feminist analyses of women's fear of crime[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 1991,15(4):415-431.
[33]	Valentine G . Images of danger: Women's sources of information about the spatial distribution of male violence[J]. Area, 1992,24(1):22-29.
[34]	吴小英 . 女性主义的知识范式[J]. 国外社会科学, 2005(3):34-43.
	[ Wu Xiaoying . Feminist knowledge paradigm. Social Sciences Abroad, 2005(3):34-43. ]
[35]	吴小英 . 当知识遭遇性别: 女性主义方法论之争[J]. 社会学研究, 2003(1):30-40.
	[ Wu Xiaoying . When knowledge encounters gender: The feminist methodology debate. Sociological Studies, 2003(1):30-40. ]
[36]	Curran M E . Geographic theorizations of sexuality: A review of recent works[J]. Feminist Studies, 2005,31(2):380-398.
[37]	Wright M W . Gender and geography II: Bridging the gap—Feminist, queer, and the geographical imaginary[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2010,34(1):56-66.
[38]	姚华松, 黄耿志, 薛德升 . 国内外女性主义地理学研究述评[J]. 人文地理, 2017,32(2):9-15.
	[ Yao Huasong, Huang Gengzhi, Xue Desheng . Reviews on Feminist Geographical Studies. Human Geography, 2017,32(2):9-15. ]
[39]	Bondi L . Feminism, postmodernism, and geography: Space for women?[J]. Antipode, 1990,22(2):156-167.
[40]	Longhurst R . Geography and gender: A 'critical' time?[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2002,26(4):544-552.
[41]	McDowell L . Doing gender: Feminism, feminists and research methods in human geography[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 1992,17(4):399-416.
[42]	Pain R . Gender, race, age and fear in the city[J]. Urban Studies, 2001,38(5-6):899-913.
[43]	Fluri J L, Piedalue A . Embodying violence: Critical geographies of gender, race, and culture[J]. Gender Place & Culture, 2017,24(4):534-544.
[44]	Pain R . Globalized fear? Towards an emotional geopolitics[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2009,33(4):466-486.
[45]	Brenner N . The limits to scale? Methodological reflections on scalar structuration[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2001,25(4):591-614.
[46]	Sweet E L, Escalante S O . Bringing bodies into planning: Visceral methods, fear and gender violence[J]. Urban Studies, 2015,52(10):1826-1845.
[47]	Sweet E L, Escalante S O . Engaging territorio cuerpo-tierra through body and community mapping: A methodology for making communities safer[J]. Gender, Place & Culture, 2017,24(4):594-606.
[48]	Mountz A . Political geography III: Bodies[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2018,42(5):759-769.
[49]	刘云刚, 王丰龙 . 尺度的人文地理内涵与尺度政治: 基于1980年代以来英语圈人文地理学的尺度研究[J]. 人文地理, 2011,26(3):1-6.
	[ Liu Yungang, Wang Fenglong . Concept of scale in human geography and politics of scale: Based on anglophone human geography since 1980s. Human Geography, 2011,26(3):1-6. ]
[50]	Smith N. Homeless/global: Scaling places [C]// Bird J, Curtis B, Putnam T, et al. Mapping the futures. London, UK: Routledge, 1993: 87-119.
[51]	陶伟, 王绍续, 朱竑 . 身体、身体观以及人文地理学对身体的研究[J]. 地理研究, 2015,34(6):1173-1187.
	[ Tao Wei, Wang Shaoxu, Zhu Hong . The body, the view of body, and the study of body in human geography. Geographical Research, 2015,34(6):1173-1187. ]
[52]	O'Campo P, Daoud N, Wright S H , et al. Conceptualizing housing instability: Experiences with material and psychological instability among women living with partner violence[J]. Housing Studies, 2016,31(1):1-19.
[53]	Meth P . Rethinking the domus in domestic violence: Homelessness, space and domestic violence in South Africa[J]. Geoforum, 2003,34(3):317-327.
[54]	Smith S J . Fear of crime: Beyond a geography of deviance[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 1987,11(1):1-23.
[55]	Warrington M . 'I must get out': The geographies of domestic violence[J]. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2010,26(3):365-382.
[56]	Kaika M . Interrogating the geographies of the familiar: Domesticating nature and constructing the autonomy of the modern home[J]. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 2004,28(2):265-286.
[57]	Lauritsen J L, Carbonelopez K . Gender differences in risk factors for violent victimization: An examination of individual-, family-, and community-level predictors[J]. Journal of Research in Crime & Delinquency, 2011,48(4):538-565.
[58]	Alvi S, Schwartz M D, Dekeseredy W S , et al. Women's fear of crime in Canadian public housing[J]. Violence against Women, 2001,7(6):638-661.
[59]	Coy M, Kelly L, Foord J , et al. Roads to nowhere? Mapping violence against women services[J]. Violence against Women, 2011,17(3):404-425.
[60]	Beyer K, Wallis A B, Hamberger L K . Neighborhood environment and intimate partner violence: A systematic review[J]. Trauma Violence Abuse, 2015,16(1):16-47.
[61]	Bucheli M, Rossi M . Attitudes toward partner violence and gender roles in Uruguayan women[J]. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 2015,32(23):3693-3705.
[62]	Haider S. Migrant women and urban experience in a squatter settlement [C]// Dupont V, Tarlo E, Vidal D. Delhi: Urban space and human destinies. New Delhi, India: Manohar, 2000: 29-49.
[63]	Benson M L, Fox G L, De Maris A, Wyk J V . Neighborhood disadvantage, individual economic distress and violence against women in intimate relationships[J]. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 2003,19(3):207-235.
[64]	Hanmer J. Women and violence: Commonalities and diversities [C]// Fawcett B, Featherstone B, Hearn J, Toft C. Violence and gender relations: Theories and interventions. London, UK: Sage, 1996: 7-21.
[65]	Price L, Evans N . From 'As Good as Gold' to 'Gold Diggers': Farming women and the survival of British family farming[J]. Sociologia Ruralis, 2010,46(4):280-298.
[66]	Little J . Understanding domestic violence in rural spaces: A research agenda[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2017,41(4):472-488.
[67]	Datta A . The intimate city: Violence, gender and ordinary life in Delhi slums[J]. Urban Geography, 2016,37(3):323-342.
[68]	Tyner J . Herding elephants: Geographic perspectives on gendered violence[J]. Dialogues in Human Geography, 2016,6(2):190-197.
[69]	Pain R . Intimate war[J]. Political Geography, 2015,44:64-73.
[70]	Pain R . Everyday terrorism: Connecting domestic violence and global terrorism[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2014,38(4):531-550.
[71]	Katz C . Towards minor theory[J]. Environment and Planning D: Society & Space, 1996,14(4):487-499.
[72]	Sharp J . Geography and gender: Finding feminist political geographies[J]. Progress in Human Geography, 2007,31(3):381-387.
[73]	Goodin R E. What's Wrong with Terrorism? [M]. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press, 2006.
[74]	Koenig M A, Lutalo T, Zhao F , et al. Domestic violence in rural Uganda: Evidence from a community-based study[J]. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2003,81(1):53-60.
[75]	Annan J, Brier M . The risk of return: Intimate partner violence in northern Uganda's armed conflict[J]. Social Science & Medicine, 2010,70(1):152-159.
[76]	Dolan C. Collapsing masculinities and weak states: A case study of northern Uganda [C]// Cleaver F. Masculinities matter! Men, gender and development. London, UK: Zed Books, 2002: 57-83.
[77]	Laliberté N . 'Peace begins at home': Geographic imaginaries of violence and peacebuilding in northern Uganda[J]. Political Geography, 2016,52:24-33.
[78]	Sjoberg L. Gendering global conﬂict: Toward a feminist theory of war [M]. New York, USA: Columbia University Press, 2013.
[79]	Jones A . They were soldiers[M]. New York, USA: Picador, 2013.
[80]	Faria C . Towards a countertopography of intimate war: Contouring violence and resistance in a South Sudanese diaspora[J]. Gender, Place & Culture, 2017,24(4):1-19.
[81]	Philo C . Insecure bodies/selves: Introduction to theme section[J]. Social & Cultural Geography, 2014,15(3):284-290.
[82]	王丰龙, 刘云刚 . 尺度政治理论框架[J]. 地理科学进展, 2017,36(12):1500-1509.
	[ Wang Fenglong, Liu Yungang . Towards a theoretical framework of 'politics of scale'. Progress in Geography, 2017,36(12):1500-1509. ]
[83]	Loyd, J M . War is not healthy for children and other living things[J]. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 2009,27(3):403-424.
[84]	Williams J, Massaro V . Feminist geopolitics: Unpacking (in)security, animating social change[J]. Geopolitics, 2013,18(4):751-758.
[85]	Hyndman J . Mind the gap: Bridging feminist and political geography through geopolitics[J]. Political Geography, 2004,23(3):307-322.