旅游地可持续发展研究综述

doi:10.11820/dlkxjz.2013.06.016

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 旅游业快速发展给旅游地带来一系列资源环境等问题, 开展旅游地可持续发展研究有助于优化旅游地生态服务功能与提升旅游业综合效益。本文首先回顾了国内外旅游地可持续发展的研究历程, 将其分为起步探索、快速发展与巩固深化3 个阶段。其次, 分析了旅游环境承载力评价、旅游环境影响评价、评价指标体系、可接受改变极限、旅游生态足迹分析等旅游地可持续发展研究方法的特点与不足。第三, 从旅游地可持续发展概念内涵与发展水平、旅游地发展演化过程与规律、旅游生态安全与环境容量、旅游可持续发展模式、居民与游客的影响感知、旅游地低碳化发展、旅游企业的影响等7 个方面对旅游地可持续发展研究进行综述。最后对中国旅游地可持续发展研究提出了建议。

关键词: 可持续发展, 旅游地, 旅游业, 研究综述

Abstract: With the rapid development of tourism, various resource and environmental problems have been constantly emerging in tourism destination areas. The research on sustainable development of tourism destinations can promote the optimization of comprehensive benefit and the exertion of ecosystem service function for tourism destinations. There have been abundant achievements in the research on sustainable development of tourism destinations at home and abroad. The research progress was reviewed from the three aspects in this paper, including research process, research methods and main research content. Firstly, the course of the research at home and abroad was summarized and divided into three phases: initial exploration, rapid development, consolidation and deepening. Secondly, main research methods were analyzed comprehensively in terms of their characteristics and the insufficiency, which include tourism environment capacity evaluation, tourism environment impact evaluation, evaluation indices, limits of acceptable change, tourism ecology footprint. Thirdly, the major research contexts were reviewed from seven aspects, including the concepts and the level of sustainable development of tourism destinations, the course and the mechanism of the development of tourism destinations, carrying capacity and ecosystem safety of the environment of tourism destinations, tourism sustainable development model, local residents' and visitors' perceptions of the impacts of tourism, low-carbon development of tourism destinations, and the impacts of tourism enterprises. Finally, the perspectives of the research on sustainable development of tourism destinations in China were put forward from the aspects of theory, methods, and content.

Key words: research review, sustainable development, tourism industry, tourist destination

唐承财, 钟林生, 成升魁. 旅游地可持续发展研究综述[J]. 地理科学进展, 2013, 32(6): 984-992.

TANG Chengcai, ZHONG Linsheng, CHENG Shengkui. A review on sustainable development for tourist destination[J]. PROGRESS IN GEOGRAPHY, 2013, 32(6): 984-992.

参考文献

[1] Ahn B Y, Lee B K, Shafer C S. 2002. Operationalizing sustainability in regional tourism planning: An application of the limits of acceptable change framework. Tourism Management, 23(1): 1-15.
[2] Bao J G, Chu Y F. 1999. Tourism geography. Beijing, China: Higher Education Press: 106-119. [ 保继刚, 楚义芳. 1999. 旅游地理学. 北京: 高等教育出版社: 106-119.]
[3] Bao J G, Yin S B, Liang Z X, et al. 2011. Development report on tourism geography in China (2005-2011). Progress in Geography, 30(12): 1506-1512 [保继刚, 尹寿兵, 梁增贤, 等. 2011. 中国旅游地理学研究进展与展望. 地理科学进展, 30(12): 1506-1512.]
[4] Butler R W. 1980. The concept of a tourism area cycle of evolution: Implications for the management of resources. Canadian Geographer, 24(1): 5-12.
[5] Castellani V, Sala S. 2012. Ecological footprint and life cycle assessment in the sustainability assessment of tourism activities. Ecological Indicators, 16(2): 135-147.
[6] Chen J L. 1991. On the potential of future crisis in Fujian's tourism and ways to solve it. Tourism Tribune, 6(1): 17-21. [陈及霖. 1991. 福建旅游业的潜在危机及其对策. 旅游学刊, 6(1): 17-21.]
[7] Cui F J, Liu J M, Li Q L. 1998. Study of the theory and application of tourism bearing capacity index. Tourism Tribune, 22(6): 41-44. [崔凤军, 刘家明, 李巧玲. 1998. 旅游承载力指数及其应用研究. 旅游学刊, 22(6): 41-44.]
[8] Cui Z H, Li Y H. 2005. A study on measurement method and management of tourism destination's carrying capacity. Journal of Yanbian University: Natural Science, 31(2): 124-129. [崔哲浩, 李英花. 2005. 试论旅游地承载力的测量及管理. 延边大学学报: 自然科学版, 31(2): 124-129.]
[9] Dearden P, Harron S. 1994. Alternative tourism and adaptive change. Annals of Tourism Research, 21(1):81-102.
[10] Sisman D. 2007. Tourism destinations carbon footprints. Bristol, UK: The Travel Foundation.
[11] Gössling S, Hansson C B, Horstmeier O, et al. 2002. Ecological footprint analysis as a tool to assess tourism sustainability. Ecological Economic, 43(2-3): 199-211.
[12] Guo L X. 1996. The theoretical and practical study on the sustainable development of tourism in China. Human Geography, 11(S1):17-25. [郭来喜. 1996. 中国旅游业可持续发展理论与实践研究. 人文地理, 11(S1): 17-25.]
[13] Gwrod B, Fyall A. 1998. Beyond the rhetoric of sustainable tourism. Tourism Management, 19(3): 199-212.
[14] Hardy A, Beeton R J S, Pearson L. 2002. Sustainable tourism: An overview of the concept and its position in relation to conceptualisations of tourism. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 10(6): 475-496.
[15] Huang Y L, Huang Z F. 2008. A study on the structural equation model and its application to tourist perception for agri-tourism destinations: Taking southwest minority areas as an example. Geographical Research, 27(6): 1455-1465. [黄燕玲, 黄震方. 2008. 农业旅游地游客感知结构模型与应用: 以西南少数民族地区为例. 地理研究, 27(6): 1455-1465.]
[16] Hunter C, Shaw J. 2007. The ecological footprint as a key indicator of sustainable tourism. Tourism Management, 28 (1): 46-57
[17] Hunter C. 2002. Sustainable tourism and the touristic ecological footprint. Environment, Development and Sustainability, 4(1): 7-20.
[18] Kelly J, Williams P W. 2007. Modelling tourism destination energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions: Whistler, British Columbia, Canada. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 15(1): 285-290.
[19] Li R J, Lu Z. 2009. The comprehensive analysis of the relationship between ecotourism and regional sustainable development in China. Progress in Geography, 28(1): 139-146. [李仁杰, 路紫. 2009.国内生态旅游与区域可持续发展关系研究. 地理科学进展, 28(1): 139-146.]
[20] Lu M. 2001. Evaluation pattern on the sustainability of tourist destination[D]. Wuhan, China: Central China Normal University. [鲁敏. 2001. 旅游地可持续发展评价模式 [D]. 武汉: 华中师范大学.]
[21] Martín-Cejas R R, Sánchez P P R. 2010. Ecological footprint analysis of road transport related to tourism activity: The case for Lanzarote Island. Tourism Management, 31(1): 98-103.
[22] Mathieson A, Wall G. 1982. Tourism: Economic, physical and social impacts. Harlow, UK: Longman.
[23] O'Reilly A M. 1986. Tourism carrying capacity: Concepts and issues. Tourism Management, 7(4): 254-258.
[24] Rodríguez J R O, Parra-López E, Yanes-Estévez V. 2008. The sustainability of island destinations: Tourism area life cycle and teleological perspectives: The case of Tenerife. Tourism Management, 29(1): 53-65.
[25] Schianetz K, Kavanagh L, Lockington D. 2007. The learning tourism destination: The potential of a learning organisation approach for improving the sustainability of tourism destinations. Tourism Management, 28(6): 1485-1496.
[26] Selby M, Morgan N G. 1996. Reconstructing place image: A case study of its role in destination market research. Tourism Management, 17(4) :287-294.
[27] Smith S L J. 1995. Tourism analysis: A handbook. London: Longman: 295-299.
[28] Stankey G H. 1981. Integrating wild land recreation research into decision making: Pitfalls and promises. Recreational Research Review, 9(1): 31-37.
[29] Su Q, Lin B Y. 2004. Classification of residents in the tourist attractions based on attitudes and behaviors: A case study in Xidi, Zhouzhuang and Jiuhua Mountain. Geographical Research, 23(1): 104-114. [苏勤. 林炳耀. 2004. 基于态度与行为的我国旅游地居民的类型划分: 以西递、周庄、九华山为例. 地理研究, 23(1): 104-114.]
[30] Tang C C. 2012. The energy consumption and carbon dioxide emissions of tourism industry of tourism destination: A case of the Wulingyuan scenic and historic interest area, China[D]. Beijing, China: University of Chinese Academy of Sciences. [唐承财. 2012. 旅游地旅游业能源消耗与碳排放研究: 以武陵源风景名胜区为例[D]. 北京: 中国科学院大学.]
[31] Tang C C, Zhong L S, Chen T. 2009. Characteristics of spatial differentiation and development modes for ecotourism resources in the Sanjiangyuan Region. Resources Science, 31(11): 1825-1833. [唐承财, 钟林生, 陈田. 2009. 三江源地区生态旅游资源空间分异特征及开发模式研究. 资源科学, 31(11): 1825-1833.]
[32] Tang C C, Zhong L S, Cheng S K. 2012. Research progress on carbon emissions in tourism industry. Progress in Geography, 31(4): 451-460. [唐承财, 钟林生, 成升魁. 2012. 旅游业碳排放研究进展. 地理科学进展, 31(4): 451-460.]
[33] Wan Y Q. 2006. The method and indicates of evaluation on sustainable development for tourism. Statistics and Decision, (2): 10-12. [万幼清. 2006. 旅游可持续发展评价指标与方法. 统计与决策, (2): 10-12.]
[34] Wang L J. 2001. On the indicator system of sustainable development of tourism and the evaluating method. Tourism Tribune, 16(1): 67-70. [王良健. 2001. 旅游可持续发展评价指标体系及评价方法研究. 旅游学刊, 16(1): 67-70.]
[35] Wight P. 1998. Tools for sustainability analysis in planning and managing tourism and recreation in the destination// Hall C M, Lew A A. Sustainable tourism: A geographical perspective. New York: AddisonWesley Longman: 75-91.
[36] Wu B H. 1996. Tourist ecology and sustainable development of tourist destinations. Chinese Journal of Ecology, 15 (2): 7-43. [吴必虎. 1996. 旅游生态学与旅游目的地可持续发展. 生态学杂志, 15(2): 7-43.]
[37] Wu J H. 2008. An analysis on the tourist area life cycle: A case study of Wuyishan City[D]. Fuzhou, China: Fujian Normal University. [吴剑豪. 2008. 旅游地生命周期分析与调控: 以武夷山市为例[D]. 福州: 福建师范大学.]
[38] Xia B Q. 2007. The evolution process of Thousand-island Lake tourism destination and its mechanism research[D]. Wuhu, China: Anhui Normal University. [夏必琴. 2007. 千岛湖旅游地演化进程及其机制研究[D]. 芜湖: 安徽师范大学.]
[39] Xiao J H, Yu Q D, Liu K, et al. 2011. Evaluation of the ecological security of island tourist destination and island tourist sustainable development: A case study of Zhoushan Islands. Acta Geographica Sinica, 66(6): 842-852. [ 肖建红, 于庆东, 刘康, 等. 2011. 海岛旅游地生态安全与可持续发展评估: 以舟山群岛为例. 地理学报, 66(6): 842-852.]
[40] Xie F Y, Zhao Y. 2010. A Study on progress of domestic and overseas low-carbon tourism and its enlightment. Human Geography, 25(5): 27-31. [谢园方, 赵媛. 2010.国内外低碳旅游研究进展及启示. 人文地理, 25(5): 27-31.]
[41] Xie F Y, Zhao Y. 2012. Measuring carbon dioxide emissions from energy consumption by tourism in Yangtze River Delta. Geographical Research, 31(3): 429-438. [谢园方, 赵媛. 2012. 长三角地区旅游业能源消耗的CO₂排放测度研究. 地理研究, 31(3): 429-438.]
[42] Xie Y J. 1994. Sustainable tourism: New concept, new subject and new challenge. Tourism Tribune, 9(1): 21-26. [谢彦君. 1994. 永续旅游: 新观念、新课题、新挑战. 旅游学刊, 9(1): 21-26.]
[43] Xu F F. 2003. Study on patterns of ecotourism and sustainable development in littoral zone: Taking Lianyungang City of Jiangsu as an example. Economic Geography, 23(7): 547-550. [徐菲菲. 2003. 滨海生态旅游地可持续发展模式研究: 以江苏连云港为例. 经济地理, 23(7): 547-550.]
[44] Xu T, Zhang Q J, Zhao L R. 2004. Review on the research of sustainable tourism development in China. Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment, 18(6): 123-127. [许涛, 张秋菊, 赵连荣. 2004. 我国旅游可持续发展研究概述. 干旱区资源与环境, 18(6): 123-127.]
[45] Xuan G F, Lu L, Zhang J H, et al. 2002. Residents' perception of tourism impacts in coast resorts: The case study of Haikou and Sanya Cities, Hainan Provine. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 22(6): 741-746. [宣国富, 陆林, 章锦河, 等. 2002. 海滨旅游地居民对旅游影响的感知: 海南省海口市及三亚市实证研究. 地理科学, 22(6): 741-746.]
[46] Yang C Y. 2009. New exploration research of reasonable threshold of tourism environment carrying capacity based on the complex system theory. China Population, Resources and Environment, 19(3): 163-168. [ 杨春宇.2009. 基于复杂系统理论的旅游地环境承载力合理阈值量测研究. 中国人口·资源与环境, 19(3): 163-168.]
[47] Yang J H. 2005. Targeting model of sustainable development in eco-tourism. Human Geography, 20(5): 74-77. [ 杨桂华. 2005. 生态旅游可持续发展四维目标模式探析. 人文地理, 20(5): 74-77.]
[48] Yang G H, Li P. 2005. Touristic ecological footprint: A new yardstick to assess sustainability of tourism. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 25(6): 1475-1480. [杨桂华, 李鹏. 2005. 旅游生态足迹: 测度旅游可持续发展的新方法. 生态学报, 25(6): 1475-1480.]
[49] Yang R. 2003. From recreation carrying capacity to LAC theory: On the new development of environment capacity concept. Tourism Tribune, 18(5): 62-65. [杨锐. 2003. 从游客环境容量到LAC理论: 环境容量概念的新发展. 旅游学刊, 18(5): 62-65.]
[50] Yang Y B, Li T S. 2007. A study on the development of rural tourist destinations in Xi'an based on the evaluation of tourists' psychological perception. Tourism Tribune, 22 (11): 32-37. [杨永波, 李同升. 2007. 基于游客心理感知评价的西安乡村旅游地开发研究. 旅游学刊, 22(11): 32-37.]
[51] Yang Y F, Luo S W, Hu C D, et al. 2009. Tourist destination life cycle early warning system research based on "Inflection Point" theory. China Population, Resources and Environment, 19(1): 110-113. [杨永丰, 罗仕伟, 胡传东, 等. 2009. 基于拐点理论的旅游地生命周期预警效应分析. 中国人口·资源与环境, 19(1): 110-113.]
[52] Yao H Q, Gao P, Zhou L Q. 2007. The dynamic analysis on environment capacity in tourism scenic spot. Economic Tribune, (9): 72-74. [姚海琴, 高萍, 周玲强. 2007. 旅游景区环境容量的动态性分析. 经济论坛, (9): 72-74.]
[53] Yu X Y, Sha R, Hu S F. 2009. Criticism and research on sustainable tourism. Economic Geography, 29(12): 2090-2095, 2084. [余向洋, 沙润, 胡善风. 2009. 可持续旅游批评与研究进展. 经济地理, 29(12): 2090-2095, 2084.]
[54] Zhang G R, Trans.. 1998a. Agenda 21 for the travel & tourism industry: Towards environmentally sustainable development( Part 1). Tourism Tribune, 13(2): 50-54. [ 张广瑞, 译. 1998a. 关于旅游业的21 世纪议程: 实现与环境相适应的可持续发展(1). 旅游学刊, 13(2): 50-5.]
[55] Zhang G R, Trans.. 1998b. Agenda 21 for the travel & tourism industry: Towards environmentally sustainable development( Part 2). Tourism Tribune, 13(3): 52-56. [ 张广瑞, 译. 1998b. 关于旅游业的21 世纪议程: 实现与环境相适应的可持续发展(2). 旅游学刊, 13(3): 52-56.]
[56] Zhang G R, Trans.. 1998c. Agenda 21 for the travel & tourism industry: Towards environmentally sustainable development( Part 3). Tourism Tribune, 13(4): 48-53. [ 张广瑞, 译. 1998c. 关于旅游业的21 世纪议程: 实现与环境相适应的可持续发展(3). 旅游学刊, 13(4): 48-53.]
[57] Zhang G R, Trans.. 1998d. Agenda 21 for the travel & tourism industry: Towards environmentally sustainable development( Part 4). Tourism Tribune, 13(5): 48-56. [ 张广瑞, 译. 1998d. 关于旅游业的21 世纪议程: 实现与环境相适应的可持续发展(4). 旅游学刊, 13(5): 48-56.]
[58] Zhang J H. 2008. Measuring the ecological impact of tourist wastes: methodology and cases study of Jiuzhaigou and Huangshan national park. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 28(6): 2764-73.[章锦河.2008.旅游废弃物生态影响评价.生态学报, 28(6): 2764-73.]
[59] Zhang J H, Zhang J. 2004. Touristic ecological footprint model and analysis of Huangshan City in 2002. Acta Geographica Sinica, 59(5): 763-771. [章锦河, 张捷. 2004. 旅游生态足迹模型及黄山实证分析. 地理学报, 59(5): 763-771.]
[60] Zhang J H, Zhang J, Wang Q. 2008. Measuring the ecological security of tourist destination: Methodology and a case study of Jiuzhaigou. Geographical Research, 27(2): 449-458. [章锦河, 张捷, 王群. 2008. 旅游地生态安全测度分析: 以九寨沟自然保护区为例. 地理研究, 27(2): 449-458.]
[61] Zhang J H, Zhang H L, Zhang J, et al. 2011. Review of studies on environmental impacts of tourism waste. Proceedings of the International Workshop on Environment Management and Energy Economic (EMEE). Zhengzhou, China: 8-10 August.
[62] Zhang J H, Li M, Chen J, et al. 2012. Analysis of environmental Kuznets Effect of tourism waste: Case study of Huangshan National Park. Acta Geographica Sinica, 67(11): 1537-1546. [章锦河, 李曼, 陈静, 等. 2012. 旅游废弃物的环境库兹涅茨效应分析: 以黄山风景区为例. 地理学报, 67(11): 1537-1546.]
[63] Zhao J L, Gao J. 2011. Assessing the low carbon mode for tourism regions based on an ANP approach. Resources Science, 33(5): 897-904. [赵金凌, 高峻. 2011. 基于ANP 法的低碳旅游景区评估模型. 资源科学, 33(5): 897-904. ]
[64] Zhao Y Z, Li D H, Huang M L.2005. On the residents' perceptions and attitudes towards tourism development in tourist destinations Overseas: A review. Tourism Tribune, 20 (4): 85-92. [赵玉宗, 李东和, 黄明丽. 2005.国外旅游地居民旅游感知和态度研究综述. 旅游学刊, 20(4): 85-92.]
[65] Zhao Y X, Zheng H Y. 2008. The exploration on evaluation system for ecological security of coastal tourist destination. Commercial Times, (28): 101-102. [ 赵莹雪, 郑海燕. 2008. 滨海旅游地生态安全评价体系初探. 商业时代, (28): 101-102.]
[66] Zhong L S, Deng J Y, Xiang B H. 2008. Tourism development and the tourism area life-cycle model: A case study of Zhangjiajie National Forest Park, China. Tourism Management, 29(5): 841-856.
[67] Zhong L S, Xiao D N. 2000. Ecotourism and its planning and management: A review. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 20(5): 841-848. [钟林生, 肖笃宁. 2000. 生态旅游及其规划与管理研究综述. 生态学报, 20(5): 841-848.]
[68] Zhou N X. 2003. Calculation of tourism social carrying capacity in mountain scenic area: A case study of Huangshizhai scenic area in Wulingyuan. Geography and Geo-Information Science, 19(2): 102-104. [周年兴. 2003. 旅游心理容量的测定: 以武陵源黄石寨景区为例. 地理与地理信息科学, 19(2): 102-104.]